group 3 too hard to pick!!!!!

[frogo]

Wow! - so much talent tonight How are we supposed to choose?? ONLY 3 to go through! This is so hard on those who don't make it.

STILL NO GUY EQUIVALENT EMERGING - NO VOICES DIFFERENT ENOUGH but Casey was the outstanding performance for me. I also love and am fascinated by Emilia and for no. 3 - Garth. - a really amazing group.
I love Billie - but think she is too jazz orented to be an idol winner. She has an assured career though.

It would be interesting to see her do other stuff though.

who did it for you?

[babooshka]

No Guy equivalent? This year far surpasses last year. And Cosima should have won, not Guy. Guy will fade into obscurity eventually, he's not really as great as you make out. Don't get me wrong, I like him, but I can't see him lasting more than five years.

Anyway, I agree that Casey was the best. And every time before that performance I really did not like her. I'd pick her, Billie and, I don't know, maybe Christie to go through, or if that's too many "fat chicks", maybe swap Christie for Emilia?

[random]

My top 3 would probably be:
-Emelia
-Ricki-Lee
-Casey (but she'll have to ditch those rat toys Yuck!)

I also really love Billie, but I just cannot for the life of me see her moving into other styles, or becoming the Australian Idol. (Although I will happily be proved wrong).

I agree that this group had too many good people in it...the people in group 2 really lucked out.

[HairBear]

babooshka said:

No Guy equivalent? This year far surpasses last year. And Cosima should have won, not Guy. Guy will fade into obscurity eventually, he's not really as great as you make out. Don't get me wrong, I like him, but I can't see him lasting more than five years.

Anyway, I agree that Casey was the best. And every time before that performance I really did not like her. I'd pick her, Billie and, I don't know, maybe Christie to go through, or if that's too many "fat chicks", maybe swap Christie for Emilia?

The fact is, Guy won because he was and is the very best and he is going to be around for a long long time

[babooshka]

We'll have to disagree here. But I can see that this board is incredibly pro-Guy. I quite like him, despite how much I dislike his version of What A Wonderful World. But I think that first album was disappointingly mediocre. I guess his future career could all come down to his next album. If it sucks I can't see him being around much longer. The difference is I see Cosima with the possibility of moving on, especially after her first song (which I love, and I hate Cold Chisel with such an immense passion).

[MaybeNext]

Way too hard to pick. They were much better this week than last week.

Mmmmm... Christie was good but a bit like Angie (my fav)... still she should have a chance.
Dan was good but needed to let go a bit more.
Casey's rats and spiders have to go. Great song though.
Emilia, Ricki, Garth, Carlos, Billie... wow they were all good really.

babooshka said:

... I like him, but I can't see him lasting more than five years.

Oh and babooshka.. in the pop industry 5 years is a long time. Most don't last that. So if Guy does that he'll be doing better than your average.

[Pickles]

Are you crazy Babooshka, this is Guy Central, you will be hunted down by the Guy army, better change your nickname dude!

[Chicagoholic]

random said:

My top 3 would probably be:
-Emelia
-Ricki-Lee
-Casey (but she'll have to ditch those rat toys Yuck!)

I agree, they're my top 3 too

[Chicagoholic]

frogo said:

STILL NO GUY EQUIVALENT EMERGING

I think we should be fair here..afterall Guy improved during the whole competition. His semi final performance would be on par with this lot.

[FreeCDs]

my voting list is ready. ;D





Thanks!

--------------------------------
Win 3 Free Australian Idol 2 Final 12 CDs now!
www.IdolTalk.com/
Australian Idol Discussion Forum

[tamstar001]

Wow I cant believe how great this group was last night, my top three would have to be Garth, and Casey they were both outstandinding and mainly because of his looks I would go for Daniel. The two I didn't like were Carlos and Emelia, What was with that dess! Damn that girl has no taste.

[Wombat]

frogo said:

Wow! - so much talent tonight How are we supposed to choose?? ONLY 3 to go through! This is so hard on those who don't make it.

STILL NO GUY EQUIVALENT EMERGING - NO VOICES DIFFERENT ENOUGH

I agree frogo... how are you my friend?

we voted for 6 of them!

[frogo board addicted]

Chicagoholic said:

I think we should be fair here..afterall Guy improved during the whole competition. His semi final performance would be on par with this lot.

about Guy - the thing that is outstanding about him is his different voice from day one!!! There are no different voices here - very good voices YES - BUT NOT VOICES THAT MAKE YOU STOP WHAT YOU ARE DOING TO CHECK HIM OUT because you haven't heard that sound before!!. Now - before you howl me down - his voice isn't LOIKE HE CAME FROM ANOTHER PLANET, but different enough!!

[frogo speaking wombat]

Wombat said:

frogo said:

Wow! - so much talent tonight How are we supposed to choose?? ONLY 3 to go through! This is so hard on those who don't make it.

STILL NO GUY EQUIVALENT EMERGING - NO VOICES DIFFERENT ENOUGH

I agree frogo... how are you my friend?

we voted for 6 of them!

hey lovely Wombat - I'm good thanks - supposed to be packing to go away, but just had to look in here.

GUESS WHAT ? - I met one of your family this weekend = the cutest little furry wombat someone found slightly injured by the side of the road. He was taken to wombat rescue and will be OK, you will be pleased to hear. - oh so cute! OI want one of my own!

[babooshka]

You don't think any voices thus far are unique? What about Courtney, Chanel and, to an extent, Ngairre? I would say these three at the very least have extremely distinctive voices from the norm.