|
|
Post by SlackA on Feb 1, 2004 1:35:27 GMT 10
I think the judges are sometimes crazy! some of the talents they let thru was not even half as good as some that they let go. like the black girl who auditioned twice..the one with the vocal coach. security asked her to leave and the coach told her to just sing to the camera.. maaan..her voice was gooooooood!! theyre crazy! and whats up with lettin that one cute guy go coz he said hed give the moneyZ to charity.. i swear..  |
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on Feb 1, 2004 2:45:14 GMT 10
i honestly cant think of anyone who they didnt let through that should of made it...maybe im just too harsh  |
|
|
|
Post by Reggietheyank on Feb 1, 2004 5:41:54 GMT 10
I don't think that they did let that gut go through..the one that said he'd give his money to charity!! They axed him!!
And the black chick...her audition was horrible!! SHe shouldn't of gone thru with that song. But when she sang outside she was amazing. Maybe they wil have a second audition for people who want to try out again...ya know the border line people. Also, her caoch was an idiot for letting her sing that song during the auditions!
|
|
|
|
Post by Reggietheyank on Feb 1, 2004 5:42:18 GMT 10
Did you guys see the Hawaii show yet??
|
|
|
|
Post by Chris on Feb 1, 2004 9:15:15 GMT 10
lol you guys must be from the US i geddit now! no its only on twice a week here in Australia. a 2hour episode on sundays and an hour on tuesdays. we have only seen New York, Atlanta and Huston and tonight we will see LA and San Fransisco. So we dont know anything about vocal coaches or people giving money to charity!  |
|
|
|
Post by random on Feb 1, 2004 12:20:13 GMT 10
I'm not surprised that the judges let both these people in, but I couldn't believe it when Paula gave that one girl so much grief about acting fake, (I think her exact words were that she was 'affected') yet they let that scooter girl in no questions asked, and were like praising her on her great personality and sense of humour. She was so fake and annoying!
|
|
|
|
Post by Reggietheyank on Feb 1, 2004 15:09:02 GMT 10
lol you guys must be from the US i geddit now! no its only on twice a week here in Australia. a 2hour episode on sundays and an hour on tuesdays. we have only seen New York, Atlanta and Huston and tonight we will see LA and San Fransisco. So we dont know anything about vocal coaches or people giving money to charity! Oops!! I am sorry Chris...I thought SlackA was an Aussie!! Hope that I did not ruin anything!! |
|
|
|
Post by SlackA on Feb 1, 2004 18:25:03 GMT 10
I'm not surprised that the judges let both these people in, but I couldn't believe it when Paula gave that one girl so much grief about acting fake, (I think her exact words were that she was 'affected') yet they let that scooter girl in no questions asked, and were like praising her on her great personality and sense of humour. She was so fake and annoying! hear hear!she wasnt all that.same with the 'affected' girl.they were both good..but not great. another girl was the one frm the army i think.. the one that cant cook..cant shoot. i thought her voice was alright compared to some. and yeah..the black gurls audition song wasnt great..but when she sang outside..i was like 'wow' and sorry for those who hasnt seen it. singapore showed the auditions on weds and thurs. so..yeah..=\ |
|
|
|
Post by RockstarPrincess on Feb 1, 2004 19:36:59 GMT 10
I couldn't believe it when Paula gave that one girl so much grief about acting fake I thought she was extremely fake. If she talked normal and maybe like she wasn't trying to suck up to someone, then maybe she wouldn't have annoyed me as much. I didn't think she was that great a singer. She had the technique maybe, but I didn't like her voice. |
|
|
|
Post by mangosquarepantz on Feb 1, 2004 19:40:58 GMT 10
i thought cabaret girl (don't noe her real name) was a good singer... i think she should've gone thru to the next round
|
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Feb 1, 2004 19:45:13 GMT 10
i thought cabaret girl (don't noe her real name) was a good singer... i think she should've gone thru to the next round I didn't like her voice or attitude or her coach and also the girl who was a cheerleader and Simon said she was going to make it to the top 10, i didn't think she was anything special either..so far none of the contestants have caught my eye.. oh..That QToe or whatever his name was had no right to be mad or bitchy to the first guy that got through..what a sore loser and his father was damn right arrogant too. |
|
|
|
Post by random on Feb 1, 2004 19:47:51 GMT 10
Well I couldn't believe that that girl in the pink dress made it in...the one who said she would spend the prize money on a car. (btw, do you win money in American Idol, or was that just a hypothetical question?) She sang way too fast and had an annoying sounding voice. We have caught up to the episode with the girl with her vocal coach who auditioned twice...I didn't think she was that bad, although I think the judges had a point when they said she didn't suit the competition. I felt a bit bad for her, until she got outside and we got a taste of her attitude. I cannot believe these people! If you don't get in, why not leave with a bit of grace instead of kicking up a big stink about it and making yourself look stupid! The ones I love the most are those who are told they are crap, and so they just stand there in silence for a moment...then start singing again! Do they really expect the judges to suddenly change their minds and agree with them?  |
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Feb 1, 2004 19:51:37 GMT 10
^^^^^
I know I know..
That William Hung guy was bad but he tooked it really well..when they turned him down, others were in denial.
The guy who said he was going to give his money to Charity..did they really turn him down because they thought that wasn't an honest answer or they were looking for answers like "I want a car"...anyways i really thought these questions were stupid.
|
|
|
|
Post by random on Feb 1, 2004 19:52:27 GMT 10
oh..That QToe or whatever his name was had no right to be mad or bitchy to the first guy that got through..what a sore loser and his father was damn right arrogant too. Agreed, what a bad sport. I hope no one with an attitude like that actually makes it into the top 10! Imagine if someone who behaved like that won the whole comp! |
|
|
|
Post by mangosquarepantz on Feb 1, 2004 19:56:02 GMT 10
I didn't like her voice or attitude or her coach and also the girl who was a cheerleader and Simon said she was going to make it to the top 10, i didn't think she was anything special either..so far none of the contestants have caught my eye.. oh..That QToe or whatever his name was had no right to be mad or bitchy to the first guy that got through..what a sore loser and his father was damn right arrogant too. i thought her voice was good, but i didn't like her attitude or her coach... i agree with u about ur comment on QToe, he was such a sore loser, and arrogant... |
|
