|
Post by Pseudo Bohemian Goddess on Feb 1, 2004 20:08:44 GMT 10
That 'cabaret' girl's voice was weird. There was something good in it, but maybe if she didn't try to sing in an overacting way it woulda been alright.
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Feb 1, 2004 20:44:03 GMT 10
She was been pushed pretty hard by her coach...i do feel sorry for her in a way.
|
|
|
Post by dhm on Feb 1, 2004 20:55:26 GMT 10
I totally agree the caberet girl was average and if he is her coach he should have behaved a bit more professionally. I thought the cheerleader was average- I think they let her through on her perky personality.
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Feb 1, 2004 21:26:31 GMT 10
What are your thoughts on the short girl who sang "I turn to you"...i thought her voice was pretty strong.
|
|
|
Post by Genotype on Feb 1, 2004 22:03:13 GMT 10
I don't really know what they are looking for to be honest. I thought Simon and Randy was too harsh on some of them.
Meh!!! It was entertaining ;D
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Feb 1, 2004 22:29:08 GMT 10
I don't really know what they are looking for to be honest. I thought Simon and Randy was too harsh on some of them. Meh!!! It was entertaining ;D What would you be looking for if you were a judge? for someone to come along and to surprise "A brand new kind of superstar image" or "a superstar image you have implanted in your mind of what success would look and sound like"?
|
|
|
Post by Pseudo Bohemian Goddess on Feb 1, 2004 22:35:48 GMT 10
What are your thoughts on the short girl who sang "I turn to you"...i thought her voice was pretty strong. She was ok, but I think maybe after some vocal coaching, she'll learn to control her voice more. Simon was actually nice to her, calling her sweetheart and stuff, which i found shocking, he knows such endearments? I'm confused with some of the choices the judges make, we'll have to wait till we hear everyone else I suppose.
|
|
|
Post by SlackA on Feb 2, 2004 2:34:16 GMT 10
She was ok, but I think maybe after some vocal coaching, she'll learn to control her voice more. Simon was actually nice to her, calling her sweetheart and stuff, which i found shocking, he knows such endearments? I'm confused with some of the choices the judges make, we'll have to wait till we hear everyone else I suppose. yeah..i thought simon was only bein nice to her cos she was different? but its nice either way.. i thought she had a good voice but so far..noone wowed me yet but that hawaiian girl that sang the fugees ready or not..she was very pretty and had a good voice. the carabret girl.i thought she had a great voice but a stupid rendition of doh wah diddy sent her packin.
|
|
|
Post by Reggietheyank on Feb 2, 2004 6:30:07 GMT 10
i thought her voice was good, but i didn't like her attitude or her coach... i agree with u about ur comment on QToe, he was such a sore loser, and arrogant... Was QToe the tall black dude that was there with his father?? If so...yeah his attitide was appalling. "The world is gonna lose out." Or whatever he said.....PPFFTT!! What an idiot. And the Father was just as bad. What a poor role model!!
|
|
|
Post by AURORAB on Feb 2, 2004 10:15:01 GMT 10
Was QToe the tall black dude that was there with his father?? If so...yeah his attitide was appalling. "The world is gonna lose out." Or whatever he said.....PPFFTT!! What an idiot. And the Father was just as bad. What a poor role model!! It seemed to me the black guy who was there with his father was mostly exagerating his attitude and bragging for the camera because he and his dad were smiling amusingly when they got outside the building - like they enjoyed they acted for the camera and got attention or something. I think his singing was just ok from what I remember, and he should know that. btw, I'm talking about the guy who said the jugdes are definitely gonna like him after Ryan said Simon and Randy only picked females to go through and no guys yet. Maybe he's Qtoe cause I don't pay attention to their names until the top 32 are selected.
|
|
|
Post by Mo on Feb 4, 2004 12:11:15 GMT 10
Just had a look at the best of the audtions(theres not many there). And so far my picks are Michael Keown the guy who sang for the pope(can the pope hear?).Sang Unchained Melody. Fantasia Barrino black girl with spiky short hair from Atlanta sang Proud Mary. Jeffrey Dingle(great name)sang Desperado. John Peter Lewis(pen sales man)sang Crazy Love. Needs a makeover clothes and hair but cute and good voice. Camille Velasco sang Ready or not here I come. Nice smoky dark tones to her voice. The pancake waitress. Katie Weber, yeah good a bit different. Amy Adams, can belt out a tune not sure how she will go with the different styles. Sang Rescue me, has the pink pixie hairdo. not sure about her might be really good, might not.
|
|
|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Feb 4, 2004 14:59:55 GMT 10
I like the dwarf girl she was gorgeous.
I was so surprised @ how powerful her voice was compared to her small appearance. Don't know about her mother though...
Yeah that dark chik with the vocal coach was weird, the coach was even weirder though. She prob woulda got thru had she sung a proper song, but her audition was a joke, so I think it better off she didn't get thru.
I felt soooooooo sorry for that Krystal girl in hawaii. Ok so she wasn't the best singer but she was much betta than some of the people they've put thru.
|
|
|
Post by Mo on Feb 4, 2004 16:08:30 GMT 10
Yep I think the girl in Hawaii was not bad, when I look at some of the so called best of the bunch. Some seem to sing in paragraphs like they are singing 2 different songs and they don't join the song together,its a very annoying trend.
|
|
bazza
Shower Crooner
Posts: 0
|
Post by bazza on Feb 4, 2004 18:38:41 GMT 10
i don,t think the judges have got it wrong yet,
if anything they have let a few through just to get their quota.
the cabaret girl was terrible and that was her boyfriend.
she was showing off for him and the cameras, but never gave a yelp in front of the judges.
simon,s questions were to test their honesty,
that,s why the pink thunderbird got through and the give it to charity guy didn,t
mo my top two on the light blue pages are michael and fantasia also.so far that is... i think the pen salesman will be right up there also , by the judges reaction
|
|
|
Post by random on Feb 5, 2004 13:22:27 GMT 10
i think the pen salesman will be right up there also , by the judges reaction I loved the pen salesman guy! (although we didn't get to see him actually sing). He somehow reminded me of Ben Folds. I loved how he was dancing around in the waiting room after he got in.
|
|