Jo
Shower Crooner
Posts: 1
|
Post by Jo on Oct 6, 2003 19:16:09 GMT 10
When I talk to people about Australian Idol, they all seem to hate Ian Dickson, who happens to be my favourite judge on the panel.
I'm a dedicated watcher of the new Australian popstar series and often agree with Dicko, more than the other judges on their comments of the finalists in this competition. People seem to be forgeting that it is Dicko that will have to work with the winner. It is a buisness. Sure I don't like to see any of the contestants in tears , I can't begin to imagine how hard it must be for them week after week performing and the pressure they feel doing this, but Dickson has a right to his own opinion and after all it is constructive. Most of the finialists have taken his advice and have reached so far - so leave Dick alone ok!
|
|
|
|
Post by DanniiBoy on Oct 6, 2003 22:29:01 GMT 10
Gee, Jo, I don't know what boards you've been reading, but I don't remember seeing any negative sentiment about Dicko.
That's not to say that there definitely hasn't been any, but if there is, it's been outweighed by the positive.
Dicko for PM! (well, maybe not...)
|
|
|
|
Post by Lulu the Guru on Oct 13, 2003 15:24:40 GMT 10
I think the contestants need to take advice from people within the industry - and these people are...
Most of the time I have agreed with Dicko's comments - however blunt they may be.....
He tells it like it is!!
;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
|
|
|
|
Post by JO on Oct 20, 2003 22:35:47 GMT 10
GEE JO I DON'T KNOW WHAT ROCK YOU HAVE BEEN HIDDING UNDER BUT DICKO IS A WASTE OF SPACE A COMPLETE LOSER HE NEEDS TO TAKE A LOOK AT HIM SELF BEFOR COMMENTING ON ANY ONE ELES. THE SHOW WOULD ME MUCH BETTER WITH OUT THAT DICKHEAD
|
|
jojo
Shower Crooner
Posts: 14
|
Post by jojo on Oct 20, 2003 23:16:33 GMT 10
Dicko is the only judge that consistently gives constructive criticism. Without this criticism, the contestants would not learn ways to improve their performances each week. I applaud Dicko for his courage in saying what he says, especially when the crowds are biased, one eyed hicks that boo and hiss everytime someone makes a comment they don't like.
Keep it up Dicko!
|
|
|
|
Post by Taylor on Oct 22, 2003 17:19:56 GMT 10
I would have to agree STOP BAGGING DICKO...... how hard would it be to be in his position!!! and still he is honest but not cruel. He does a great job as a judge, and the truth is , he says what many people think but are afraid to actually say, which actually does the competitors a huge favour. the music idustry takes talent and hard work and is not for the try hard sooky bums, pass my dummy please. love ya's all. ;D
|
|
|
|
Post by Bernice on Oct 23, 2003 0:50:58 GMT 10
although i thought his comment regarding Paulini's weight was horrid........i thought his explanation last Monday night was plausible and i do believe he is was been sincere.
|
|
|
|
Post by DICKOISBEST on Oct 23, 2003 9:27:56 GMT 10
You morons,
I can't believe that NO ONE has heard the EXACT comments!
Dicko DID't said she was overweight, but suggested that only if she wants to get in outfits like that, then she'll need to lose some pounds. So, be honest !
I don't think Paulini is overweight, or needs to lose weight, BUT if she wants to squeeze herself in those kind of outfits, she should think twice!!!!
Isn't that true?
And stop with this nonsence!
|
|
