Tell us what you think of the judges

[Inside Australian Idol]

Leave any comments about the judges of Asutralian Idol here

[Yasmin]

The three judges are the most beautiful people , i beleve must be finding there job very hard at the moment because there is so much tallent, and so many beautiful people there. . . . .
TEXT

[GroovyLavaLamp]

I guess they got a job to do - and if that means being total buttwipes (in place of harsh expletive), so be it?

I dunno why they got this Mark dude in there, I don't even know who the hey he is...guess he was the cheapest they could afford. Sad, two-bit has-been with a bit too much plastic surgery..

[Ben]

Hmm... I thought they were a bit annoying and predicable. However they delievered some great one liners "your voice just isn't good enough to hide the whale" or something along those lines. I couldn't stop laughing.

I can't believe some of the people they let through though, like that long haired avril-wannabe guy. WTF? Oh and btw, talk about an embarrassment for Adelaide!

[karen diva]

The judges..

Well Dicko personally he was alright to me in my melbourne audition but still came across really arrogant. But he is there to make money out of that Australian idol so i guess he has the right to be.

Mark Holden: Well he is just as arrogant but like i said he was nice to me and was undecided about letting me through. But to the other auditioners who did have talent they were making comments on there dress styles and shoes which was pathetic on there behalf.

( remember they edited alot of the lines.. )

Marcia: Well she has this stigma saying she is a nice and fair person. I thought she was jsut as bad as the other judges and I think the whole show is all to make ratings.. So It's all for the camera's..

And the auditioners shouldnt take it so hard. Because they have to narrow it down and of course make up crap about your clothing and your hair etc.. to not put you through.

[Ben]

LOL, it was pretty terrible of Marcia laughing her head of at this one person. Then complaining later "everybody is a teddy bear - boo hoo".

[Caspersmum]

I think some of the comments were a little OTT, but not too bad.

It would be a LONG day to sit there and listen to a bunch of amateurs singing. I'd have been reaching for the JB bottle by about 10:00am.

[Ben]

is it true people had to go through preliminary auditions before they got to those three judges with the cameras?

[Pimp]

Hi Guys,

I love the way that the Judges have done there Job, they have to keep it up so we are able to get the BEST that Australia has to offer

[Ben]

Yes, just like Scott Cain.

[mean bean]

i've put what I think on another chat site so won't go into too much detail here
marcia - stop crying, is it really so special evey farking time some one sings
dicko - love you, great hair. sex bomb sex bomb... baby you can turn me on
other guy - who what where when... what's all that about?

I've been reading some crap about the psycological damage being done to some of the auditioners, and I think - get over it. You all knew the format of the show. Peace love and understanding doesn't sell. And I didn't see one person who didn't make it that should've. Thankgod for the judges. Infact, I think it should all be the judges decision knowing the kind of people who will be voting. Scott Cain was a travesty. only nearly pipped at the bottom rung of the post by "Scandalous". I pray that Australia won't have to suffer any cultural cringe because of our ( false) idols.

[Gwyn]

I kinda think Mark is kinda hot, but i alwayz go 4 tha 1z who r way b yond my reach

[Pinkline Jones]

MARCIA - she's just sensational. A 50yo megababe! Wish she had ripped into some of the losers a bit more though - some of them were truly forgettable. Really they should just abandon the whole contest and let Marcia sing - cause she's the only STAR on the entire show.

MARK HOLDEN - Two hit wonder from the 70s - the karaoke Max Bygraves of his time. And how come roses never worked with the bar girls for me.

DICCKO - Straight shooter which was funny and needed. However Marcia was right - a good song is a good song no matter when it was written. Dicko - try writing a hit and seeing how you get on.


MARCIA MARCIA MARCIA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Dicko rocks]

I reckon Dicko is great! All the contestants pay him out and hate him, only because he says the truth and the truth hurts! Gosh!! i swear some of the contestant are total idiots!

They all have a go at Dicko beacuse he said something 'mean' I would say get over it, if you can't take constructive critiscm then you're in the wrong industry mate, coz it's gonna get even worse if you're under the constant eye of the public as the Australian Idol!

Let me say Dicko, I appreciate guys like you mate, coz you know your stuff, you've got blinkin' 20 or so years of experience! I'm a singer myself and if it wasn't for my music teacher, who pushed me and told me where I got it wrong, I wouldn't have the mental strength and confidence I have today when I sing.

Cheers!
P.S. Guy, I'll be voting for you all the way!! It's such a privilege to know you and to sing with you at Paradise. God bless you!

[miao chairman]

I love and adore dicko.
He is smart. witty. quick.
He looks great in his swimsuit.
He is honest.
He is reliable, in that I always laugh with him, and hate with him.
And the most attractive thing about him is his success.