Post by Inside Australian Idol on Nov 10, 2003 3:17:58 GMT 10
TV music boss defends Idol worship
By Tony Davis
November 10, 2003
Australian Idol is not harmful to music, or the music industry. Simon Jones, managing director of Fremantle Music, describes as "sour grapes" comments by European MTV boss Brent Hansen that the Idol franchise was harming the music industry and singers produced by it had no value from a musical point of view.
Jones, now rolling Idol out around the world (20 countries and growing), claimed the hit TV reality show had reawakened interest in the charts.
U2 singer Bono was quoted last week as saying: "People are sick to the teeth of processed and hyped pop bands. It is crap."
"True," responded Jones. "There's been a lot of accusations of manufactured bands, but how can you manufacture an individual? If you look at the winner in the UK, Will Young, I'd say he's anything but manufactured.
"And also if you look at what (the Idol phenomenon) has done for the UK record industry, which was in a very poor state, it has created an amazing amount of interest in the charts."
In the Australian version last night the last two contestants staged a "showdown" watched by up to 4 million Australians.
Guy Sebastian, from Adelaide, sang Crazy in Love by Beyonce, and the Jackson Five song I'll Be There. Shannon Noll, from Condobolin in NSW, sang the Jimmy Barnes song Working Class Man and Please Forgive Me by Bryan Adams.
And, in a deft commercial move, both also sang Angels Brought Me Here, a ballad to be released as a single by the winner soon after the Opera House finale on November 19.
www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/11/09/1068329422449.html
By Tony Davis
November 10, 2003
Australian Idol is not harmful to music, or the music industry. Simon Jones, managing director of Fremantle Music, describes as "sour grapes" comments by European MTV boss Brent Hansen that the Idol franchise was harming the music industry and singers produced by it had no value from a musical point of view.
Jones, now rolling Idol out around the world (20 countries and growing), claimed the hit TV reality show had reawakened interest in the charts.
U2 singer Bono was quoted last week as saying: "People are sick to the teeth of processed and hyped pop bands. It is crap."
"True," responded Jones. "There's been a lot of accusations of manufactured bands, but how can you manufacture an individual? If you look at the winner in the UK, Will Young, I'd say he's anything but manufactured.
"And also if you look at what (the Idol phenomenon) has done for the UK record industry, which was in a very poor state, it has created an amazing amount of interest in the charts."
In the Australian version last night the last two contestants staged a "showdown" watched by up to 4 million Australians.
Guy Sebastian, from Adelaide, sang Crazy in Love by Beyonce, and the Jackson Five song I'll Be There. Shannon Noll, from Condobolin in NSW, sang the Jimmy Barnes song Working Class Man and Please Forgive Me by Bryan Adams.
And, in a deft commercial move, both also sang Angels Brought Me Here, a ballad to be released as a single by the winner soon after the Opera House finale on November 19.
www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/11/09/1068329422449.html