|
Post by guest on May 21, 2004 12:02:21 GMT 10
What adultery, denial and rascist comment?
Now THAT is offensive!
|
|
|
Post by guest on May 21, 2004 12:05:31 GMT 10
Trust u super c ;D ;D to see the funny side of it....
|
|
|
Post by Sunflower on May 21, 2004 12:29:09 GMT 10
You generalise too much. I don't think the ones who put Shannon down are necessarily Guy's fans. I happen to know lots of people who are not Guy's fans but they surely hate Shannon (for his voice, adultery, denial, racist comment, etc..etc). What do you say about that? Personally, I don't care what Shannon does. To many, he's got more than what he deserves, I say good on him. I think it's time for Shannon's fans to stop whining about how good Shannon is and how better he is than Guy. There's no point on doing that as it will only trigger those who dislike Shannon to make nasty comment about him. Cheers too.. Ok I might have my say now, and all I have to say is that people who think someone has had more success than they deserve are just downright mean! How the hell would you know what they deserve? Think before you type. And maybe it is time for some people to stop saying Shannon is better than Guy, but you neglect the fact that most (on this board anyway) rabid fans are those saying Shannon is no good (INCLUDING YOURSELF - or are you too blinded to see what a hypocrit you sound like?) And as for adultery, denial and racist comments - You should be so ashamed for saying something like that. So ashamed that I am not even going to comment apart from hoping that someone with such prejudice and disrespect will not bother themselves with posting here again.
|
|
|
Post by Bored on May 21, 2004 12:36:38 GMT 10
Ok I might have my say now, and all I have to say is that people who think someone has had more success than they deserve are just downright mean! How the hell would you know what they deserve? Think before you type. And maybe it is time for some people to stop saying Shannon is better than Guy, but you neglect the fact that most (on this board anyway) rabid fans are those saying Shannon is no good (INCLUDING YOURSELF - or are you too blinded to see what a hypocrit you sound like?) And as for adultery, denial and racist comments - You should be so ashamed for saying something like that. So ashamed that I am not even going to comment apart from hoping that someone with such prejudice and disrespect will not bother themselves with posting here again. Please stop this thread. It's so dead boring. What is it good for? Who cares if some crazy fans badmouthing others? Do we have too much free time? :-(
|
|
|
Post by Sunflower on May 21, 2004 12:39:28 GMT 10
Please stop this thread. It's so dead boring. What is it good for? Who cares if some crazy fans badmouthing others? Do we have too much free time? :-( Or do you have too much free time to be reading something you don't care about and then telling people they have too much free time to be posting in it? Think about it... LOL
|
|
|
Post by Bored on May 21, 2004 12:42:50 GMT 10
Or do you have too much free time to be reading something you don't care about and then telling people they have too much free time to be posting in it? Think about it... LOL OK...Ok... maybe I shouldn't have said that. But please stop this boring thread. And this is not only to you Sunflower, but to everyone. Thanks.
|
|
|
Post by guest on May 21, 2004 12:56:10 GMT 10
You generalise too much. I don't think the ones who put Shannon down are necessarily Guy's fans. I happen to know lots of people who are not Guy's fans but they surely hate Shannon (for his voice, adultery, denial, racist comment, etc..etc). What do you say about that? Personally, I don't care what Shannon does. To many, he's got more than what he deserves, I say good on him. I think it's time for Shannon's fans to stop whining about how good Shannon is and how better he is than Guy. There's no point on doing that as it will only trigger those who dislike Shannon to make nasty comment about him. Cheers too.. In this instance it was directed at a poster who was talking about Guy so he was a Guy fan.. not generalising.. And the world is a big place, do not expect EVERONE to like Shannon...same would be applied to Guy... read what superc said before... good and bad in every category ..and I am very doubtful about the rest of what you said... He is a young man who comes across as being cheeky sometimes but I do not think he is stupid... And there are also a lot of people out there I know of who do not care about that aspect of his life... he is a singer, not a saint. Make themselves sound like they themselves are perfect and righteous. It's ok if you don't care about what Shannon does but alot of his fans do... just by standing up for him shows how much they care obviously.. Never said Shannon was better than Guy.... they are their own man with their own styles...only said he might have done better cos of what the world perceive they want in an idol judging by the different standings of other singers.
|
|
|
Post by guest on May 21, 2004 13:08:58 GMT 10
Yay Yay Yaaaay for sunflower....you rock!!
|
|
|
Post by Randy on May 21, 2004 13:29:54 GMT 10
This is one helluva confusing thread to follow... but I'd like to say:
- both Shan and Guy have good things and bad things in their own ways, so everyone has rights to like or dislike any of them. - AI has long gone, and both of them have made albums. Both of them are quite successful, IMO. Doesn't matter who the winner was. - About the allegations (adultery, etc..etc), doesn't that make Shan more famous cos people want to know more about his life?
A few of us gets a bit too emotional on this matter. I think you should cool down a bit. As Sunrise said: think before you type.
My 2 cents.. :-)
|
|
|
Post by intrigued on May 21, 2004 13:34:58 GMT 10
This is one helluva confusing thread to follow... but I'd like to say: - About the allegations (adultery, etc..etc), doesn't that make Shan more famous cos people want to know more about his life? My 2 cents.. :-) where theres smoke theres fire. it wouldnt suprise me if those allegations of adultery were true. sorry shannon fans just expressing my opinion and i have every right to! with regards to the racist remarks, that wouldnt suprise me either coz he comes from a hick town and we all know how they feel about non whites! and by da way i am a paulini fan!
|
|
|
Post by UniqueShaz on May 21, 2004 13:42:28 GMT 10
I was never really exposed to the tall poppy syndrome... till now. lol. let's just all be happy that both contestants have become succesful.
Guy fans have no reason to bag Shannon... Guy won after all and what is the point of perpetuating a competition that ended a long time ago.
And shannon fans have no reason to bag Guy... they practically got the same record deal (except he got a home system as well! lol) so there is no reason to be bitter.
Personally I think having the AUstralian Idol title fixed to his name could potentially hinder Guy's success.
So if some shit (can I say that?) stirer wants to come on here and... stir, don't give them the satisfaction of replying! it jsut gives them more reason to fire back.
|
|
|
Post by Sunflower on May 21, 2004 13:43:36 GMT 10
where theres smoke theres fire. it wouldnt suprise me if those allegations of adultery were true. sorry shannon fans just expressing my opinion and i have every right to! with regards to the racist remarks, that wouldnt suprise me either coz he comes from a hick town and we all know how they feel about non whites! and by da way i am a paulini fan! Sorry but I do find this offensive, as would Shannon, his family, his fans and everyone living in a so called 'country hick town'. Of course you can have an opinion but when they are hurtful and offensive sometimes it's best to keep it to yourself. If you don't have anything nice to say then don't say anything at all?
|
|
|
Post by guest on May 21, 2004 13:49:37 GMT 10
intrigued.. how do you feel about the fact that Guy and Shannon got on so famously together?? And some psychic said that Shannon and guy were brothers in a previous life and Shannon wholeheartedly agree saying he and Guy and his brothers all get along very well...mmm a bit contradictory don't you think?
You are entitled to your opinion .. hick town or not...you are generalising....gee I am starting another argument there!! heheheh.....there are some nice photos of Shannon and fans who are not white that I have seen and they said oodles of good things about meeting Shan.. He is definitely not rascist.
I am a Paulini fan too ..she was my second favourite..rate her above Guy...am I starting another argument!! Hope not..... ;D
As for allegations.... true or not there are a lot of Shann fans who are females who wish it was them!!!! They would not care if he was playing the field or not!!! Some women are worse than men when it comes to adultery.
Poor Rochelle..she is the one who has to be strong in the midst of all this!! I hope she does not get too hurt!! I feel for her and good luck to her and Shan...
|
|
|
Post by SoCrazyInLoveWithGUY on May 21, 2004 15:51:13 GMT 10
Hi all
I'm a obsessive, crazed GUY fan.
Suprised? You didn't know that, did you!
Don't like it when people bag GUY but hey....I love him! and so do heaps of other fans.
I would never put down Shan or anyone elses Idol for that matter. What's the point in that? If Shan fans love Shan half as much as I love GUY then good on them! I think that's really groovy.
|
|
|
Post by Hippo on May 21, 2004 16:05:20 GMT 10
and by da way i am a paulini fan! shades of pinky!
|
|