|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Apr 11, 2004 21:39:05 GMT 10
What did you guys think of the new results set-up? With the whole Group A, B and C thing. I could immediately tell which group was which. JPL was in the middle group which aint too bad but I'm hoping that JPL fans will vote overtime next week! I hear the theme next week will be songs from movies which will be great I'm sure! (But don't quote me on that!) I'm glad Diana wasn't in the bottom two. Was sad Camille had to leave cos I luv her voice but I do agree that her performances, while good, haven't been up to the standard of everyone else's. I hate that JPL always gets sucky comments from the judges no matter wat he does. Maybe Im biased cos im practically in luv wit tha guy but they told him to cut down on the "crazy dancing" which he did then they say it was betta the otha way so he goes half-way and then Simon tells him he needs singing lessons! I just dont think that they appreciate his unique voice which is sad but I'm glad he has such a huge fan base that he always gets thru anyways! A lot of people are gonna bite my head off for this but after watching the show tonite I have to say that I really don't like Fantasia. I liked her in the semi-finals but since being in the top 12 she just really gets on my nerves! Every song she finishes with "yeah-yeah-yeah-yeah!" no matter what it is. In my opinion she completely butchered "Something About The Way You Look Tonight" by screeching it, as Simon says. She just seems so obnoxious to me, but like I said that's just my opinion so please dont yell at me! Who do u think will go next week? I think it will be Jennifer or Jasmine but it really does depend on their performances. Are they going to do the group thing every week? Anyways I'm carryin on too much wat did u guys think of the performances and results?
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Apr 11, 2004 21:53:22 GMT 10
Hi, Idol Obsessed..I'm sorry to offend you but i thought JPL should be in the bottom 3 along with John Stevens.
John Stevens was horrible tonight, the dancing was also off, I think he should go next week if he does bad again and JPL too.
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on Apr 11, 2004 22:37:11 GMT 10
i dont dislike her. but yeah i agree with simon is was probaly one of of weaker performances.
I think either diana, jamine or jennifer will go next week. but u are right it does depend on their performance.
|
|
|
Post by random on Apr 11, 2004 23:55:50 GMT 10
I am surprised Fantasia wasn't in the top 3-I thought she was the hot favourite. (I'm assuming her group was the middle...i can't bring myself to imagine that John Stevens managed top 3 this week-middle 3 is unbelievable enough!) I haven't been a huge Fantasia fan, but I loved her performance this week. But the performance of the night was GEORGE! ;D Man, I freakin love that guy-he just can't hold back his happiness! And the crowd was going totally insane for him-my predictions of him becoming a favourite are coming to light. I'm starting to shift from the JPL camp-I hope George wins. As for (my now 2nd fave) JPL...man, he has the most gorgeous unique voice, and it totally suited that song. And he is so friggin adorable. But he doesn't perform with energy anymore-whatever happened to the crazy Elvis dancing days? As for the worst performance of the night...do I even need to say his name? Sorry John Stevens, but that was so crap! I love his voice and love it when he does old skool big band performances...but geez, he stunk! I couldn't even watch, I felt too embarassed for him! Even his parents were laughing! Wrong song for you, John!
|
|
|
Post by superc on Apr 12, 2004 0:10:20 GMT 10
It'll be between Diana and Jennifer to go next week. It's hard because Diana fans will be going overboard to keep her in after she hit bottom three, but Jennifer doesn't have an established fanbase. I think she'll also go back to doing her over-the-top, blasting performances once again. But I think it'll be Diana. I still love Fantasia, though I understand that it's an irritating sound to most people, Idol Obsessed And I LIKED Jasmine! ARGH!!!! Maybe it was because she wasn't pimped like crazy and got less praise than she deserved this time. I agreed with Paula- her softer, colourful, non-belted notes are her strength and she should stick with those rather than power ballads. So sad that Camile went, but it was her time. JS made me laugh ;D Poor little dude... they should be nicer to him- he's only 16.
|
|
K
Back up Vocals
Posts: 187
|
Post by K on Apr 12, 2004 1:37:04 GMT 10
I don't mind the new 3-group thing I hope Diana doesn't go, because I like her ;D
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on Apr 12, 2004 1:58:06 GMT 10
its seems like he is struggling. poor thing. it just me or is he getting less confident? idol is really damneding and im not sure if JP can cope
|
|
|
Post by Edster on Apr 12, 2004 9:52:29 GMT 10
George rocks.......He is my pick for the winner of this competition. He is on a roll. I don't see anything unique with any of the other contestants. ;D
|
|
|
Post by Ava on Apr 12, 2004 13:25:00 GMT 10
i love george and diana...and camille *wipes tear*
|
|
|
Post by Sunflower on Apr 12, 2004 14:50:03 GMT 10
A lot of people are gonna bite my head off for this but after watching the show tonite I have to say that I really don't like Fantasia. I liked her in the semi-finals but since being in the top 12 she just really gets on my nerves! Every song she finishes with "yeah-yeah-yeah-yeah!" no matter what it is. In my opinion she completely butchered "Something About The Way You Look Tonight" by screeching it, as Simon says. She just seems so obnoxious to me, but like I said that's just my opinion so please dont yell at me! I totally agree with what you said about Fantasia, the thing I don't like about her is her attitude to the whole thing, you are right how you said obnoxious.
|
|
|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Apr 12, 2004 17:13:18 GMT 10
But the performance of the night was GEORGE! ;D Man, I freakin love that guy-he just can't hold back his happiness! And the crowd was going totally insane for him-my predictions of him becoming a favourite are coming to light. Hehe yeah I love George also. I think it's fantastic that he is so enthusiastic about the whole comp and that he doesn't take being there for granted. I know I've said this before somewhere but if he wins I have a feeling he would just be soooo great to his fans. I forgot to mention that his performance last night was fantastic! (but he always is As for (my now 2nd fave) JPL...man, he has the most gorgeous unique voice, and it totally suited that song. And he is so friggin adorable. But he doesn't perform with energy anymore-whatever happened to the crazy Elvis dancing days? Yeah as much as I totally completely love all of his performances, even the slower ones (I thought "She Believes In Me" was awesome") sometiems I do miss his "crazy dancing" days. But the whole reason he doesn't do that any more is because of the bloody judges confusing the hell outta him! So let's blame them .
|
|
|
Post by Maddyn on Apr 12, 2004 17:22:33 GMT 10
I thought "She Believes In Me" was awesome" So did I! sometiems I do miss his "crazy dancing" days. But the whole reason he doesn't do that any more is because of the bloody judges confusing the hell outta him! So let's blame them . I want to see him do a rock song. Air guitars and all
|
|
|
Post by random on Apr 13, 2004 1:11:31 GMT 10
I want to see him do a rock song. Air guitars and all YES! JPL air guitaring is a must! ;D
|
|
|
Post by Chicagoholic on Apr 13, 2004 1:58:45 GMT 10
A lot of people are gonna bite my head off for this but after watching the show tonite I have to say that I really don't like Fantasia. I liked her in the semi-finals but since being in the top 12 she just really gets on my nerves! Every song she finishes with "yeah-yeah-yeah-yeah!" no matter what it is. In my opinion she completely butchered "Something About The Way You Look Tonight" by screeching it, as Simon says. She just seems so obnoxious to me, but like I said that's just my opinion so please dont yell at me! IMO I don't feel she screeched it..but for those who do feel that she did that..did you notice that she at least wasnt out of tune when she did it? Unlike some of the other contestants who hit a lot of bad notes. And while I get why people find her attitude annoying..at least she isnt being fake. With Fantasia, what you see is what you get.
|
|
|
Post by Mo on Apr 13, 2004 13:56:59 GMT 10
I would say the best performers were George,LaToya and Fantasia, I missed Jennifers song but heard that she was good. Camille was definately the worst followed a close second by John Stevens then Diana and JPL, in that order. I didn't think Jasmine was that bad. Just shows how good Elton is! They did the elton walking in thing on the U.K pop idol too. Hope John Stevens goes next week, I hate the way he stares at the floor almost and you never get inside his head. He seems totally emotionless to me. Maybe after next week it will get harder to pick who is going to go.
|
|