|
Post by devil2003 on Nov 11, 2003 13:59:57 GMT 10
i seriusly think that guy should give up now as we all know who is going to win because shannon has a voice like no other : TEXT
|
|
SHANNON TAKES THE CAKE
Guest
|
Post by SHANNON TAKES THE CAKE on Nov 11, 2003 14:19:32 GMT 10
i agree with you swinger!!!
I too was a GUy fan.......but it's SHANNON ALL THE WAY now.
WOrking class man was such a top class effort. He's great. Plus, i hate guy's feminine touch. I want an Australian idol who has passion & personality.
SHANNON TAKES THE CAKE!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by zzzzzzzzzzzzzz on Nov 11, 2003 14:23:33 GMT 10
SHANNON TAKES THE CAKE!!!!! From what I saw, he's taking the biscuits (funds anyway)
|
|
|
Post by LukeS on Nov 11, 2003 14:44:26 GMT 10
If you really look at Guy's performances, you will notice that he is the one that can only sing one style. That is great if you like Stevie Wonder. Shannon on the other hand is very versatile as he has proven over the course of the show. Shannon has sung everything from Frank Sinatra to Jimmy Barnes. Shannon also proved that he was the superior performer last night with fantastic perfomances of Bryan Adams and Jimmy Barnes. Poor old guy was relegated to a Jackson Five song(can you believe he did that? ) and a female pop song. Then there was the performance of the new single. If ever there was a way to compare the two singers, this was it and I must say Shannon Blitzed it and walked all over Guy. In saying that though, both are fantastic performers and both have their own style. Good luck to both of them. If you are voting and want a representative on the world stage for Australia remember this. Guy blends in with all the other lolliPOP singers around at the moment. Shannon's stle is classic and will carry him through for years. I agree with you leelo. Guy is quite a magician as far as performing goes...and hell Ive enjoyed some of his performances too..but his tyle of singing ala Stevie Wonder isnt for one, original enough for me and 2. His choice of songs really worries me...I follow an artist for what THEY think is worthy of singing and altho Guy seems to have the edge vocally his song choices suck!!
|
|
|
Post by Carlie on Nov 11, 2003 15:00:03 GMT 10
My advice to Shannon supporters: Don't waste your money on voting for him, go down and buy a lottery ticket and you will have more of a chance of winning. Shannon wouldn't stand a chance in world idol...or in the celebrity world.
If you have taped AI from the beginning, I suggest you go and sit down and flick through it and you will notice that Shannon is clearly not idol material...he doesn't really have any true passion for music...he is what, nearly 30 and the closest thing relating to music that he has done is sing in a pub....?
I'd say 75% of all Shannon supporters are just suckers who have fallen in love with his looks or sympathise for him..it is unlikely you are just supporting him solely on his so called musical talents.
I also just wanna say that if there is a second series I hope AI are more careful with their voting system and publicity...coz it sucks!
|
|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 11, 2003 17:53:33 GMT 10
i seriusly think that guy should give up now as we all know who is going to win because shannon has a voice like no other : TEXTWhat? The ugliest voice HAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH "seriusly" though?
|
|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 11, 2003 17:57:03 GMT 10
My advice to Shannon supporters: Don't waste your money on voting for him, go down and buy a lottery ticket and you will have more of a chance of winning. Shannon wouldn't stand a chance in world idol...or in the celebrity world. TRUEIf you have taped AI from the beginning, I suggest you go and sit down and flick through it and you will notice that Shannon is clearly not idol material...he doesn't really have any true passion for music...he is what, nearly 30 and the closest thing relating to music that he has done is sing in a pub....? Done that and .. yeh he is NOT THE IDOL MATERIAL..but I saw Guy SHINE FROM THE VERY START. GO GUY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by kitten on Nov 11, 2003 18:05:19 GMT 10
Most Shannon fans are going for him because of his looks . It's so freakin OBVIOUS!!! actually you're wrong there. shannon's fairly good looking, but i like his voice, his style & the songs he sings. i would not vote for someone based on their looks - you can't see them when you're listening to their cd, can you? accept that other people have different tastes in music to you, & that EVERYONE does not like Guy's music!
|
|
|
Post by Syrup on Nov 11, 2003 19:53:42 GMT 10
i agree with you swinger!!! I too was a GUy fan.......but it's SHANNON ALL THE WAY now. WOrking class man was such a top class effort. He's great. Plus, i hate guy's feminine touch. I want an Australian idol who has passion & personality. SHANNON TAKES THE CAKE!!!!! speaking of "swinger" , I wonder where this poster got to. I've been keen to for him/her to answer a question I addressed him/her with on the previous page. Since you agree with the said swinger going by your above quote, perhaps you could take the liberty of answering. It's to do with the X factor... Also, since you say you have also changed preferences, I'd also be interested in reading your posts when you supported Guy; you know, just to compare things... cheers, Syrup
|
|
|
Post by Looloo on Nov 12, 2003 0:22:08 GMT 10
Not likely!! Shannon has hit many bad notes throughout the comp. Even the judges know this! He has a very flat voice in the lower registers. And who wants to be represented by a Jimmy Barnes clone?I'm sure Guy could sing every song that Shannon has sung extremely well- and in key. Could Shannon sing Guy's songs with the same credibility? Doubt it very much.
|
|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 12, 2003 5:45:31 GMT 10
actually you're wrong there. shannon's fairly good looking, but i like his voice, his style & the songs he sings. i would not vote for someone based on their looks - you can't see them when you're listening to their cd, can you? accept that other people have different tastes in music to you, & that EVERYONE does not like Guy's music! uhmm... I said "MOST" than if you're not one of the "MOST" why react? Did I say "EVERYONE" likes it? If "EVERYONE" likes Guy's Music I wouldn't be here arguing. LOL you can't see them when you're listening to their cd, can you? - You can have those little papers included on the CD which have their photos and stuff. LOL
|
|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 12, 2003 5:47:50 GMT 10
Not likely!! Shannon has hit many bad notes throughout the comp. Even the judges know this! He has a very flat voice in the lower registers. And who wants to be represented by a Jimmy Barnes clone?I'm sure Guy could sing every song that Shannon has sung extremely well- and in key. Could Shannon sing Guy's songs with the same credibility? Doubt it very much. Doubt it too!!! I wonder How he'll go with Climb Every Mountain. LOL I bet he'll yell the high notes ;D and as "Ala" said LOL Shannon having a go with "Crazy In Love" Oh God $#%#$^#$^#$
|
|
|
Post by Leelo on Nov 12, 2003 10:13:32 GMT 10
Why is it that Guy fans seem to think they have to bag Shannon? Is it insecurity or just immaturity?
|
|
|
Post by same on Nov 12, 2003 14:18:32 GMT 10
same reason shannon fans bag guy.
|
|
|
Post by bijy on Nov 12, 2003 22:57:00 GMT 10
toche! does anyone read my posts? maybe i should be more contraversial and start bagging someone?? one more thing, i wonder how many people noticed (commented) that shannon has any sort of trouble in his "lower register" and that guy doesnt "respect the melody" before dicko used those exact words? hmmm yes i wonder....
|
|