|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 10, 2003 16:21:49 GMT 10
I taped the whole show from day one and Guy always STANDS OUT !!!!!!!!
GUY IS THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!GUY FOR AI
|
|
|
|
Post by Swinger on Nov 10, 2003 16:35:22 GMT 10
I used to think so too, but changed my mind after last night
|
|
|
|
Post by reply to swinger on Nov 10, 2003 16:45:17 GMT 10
you know what swinger? I think you're faking it and that you have been a Shannon fan since the start. You're just using a bit of reverse psychology ("I was going to vote for Guy but not anymore") on the forums as a way of grasping hopelessly for more votes for Shannon!
Guy's got the goods
(just having some fun by the way, don't get defensive, this forums thing is all new to me)
|
|
|
|
Post by Swinger on Nov 10, 2003 16:51:39 GMT 10
I doubt any guy supporter will swing over cause of what i say. I'm just telling you how i feel. Guy has done so well but he just doesnt excite me anymore. I can see ( or hear )shannons short comings but there is just something there that I like. I don't really think you can compare the two they are too different. They don't have to win idol to make names for themselves the real test is after idol.
|
|
|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 10, 2003 19:22:52 GMT 10
blah blah blah  GUY FOR OZ IDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
|
|
Post by Syrup on Nov 10, 2003 20:24:56 GMT 10
Shanon absolutely slaughtered guy last night. I was a guy fan the man can sing. Shanon misses a few notes and still gets the crowd in. Someone was talking about X factor. The person who doesnt sing perfectly and still attracts the crowd has that x factor. I used to think it was Guy, iwas wrong its been shannon all the time. I'm changing my vote!! Well hec there Swinger! If a person who doesn't sing perfectly and still attracts the crowd has that X factor, then since Guy CAN sing much better (you implied this in your argument), what does that give him? XXX perhaps? I think if you are going to swing based on a logic, you ought to either get back on that vine and swing right back to the Guy camp or at least come up with a better argument since you've decided to place yours on a discussion board. Best wishes to both, they've both worked so hard. Thing is though, GUY is in a league of his own. Seriously, think about the X factor thing! I'm not knocking you for liking Shannon. He seems like a nice person and he's had it tough. I just can't find logic in the reason you gave for 'swinging'. cheers Syrup. |
|
|
|
Post by ophelia on Nov 10, 2003 23:40:13 GMT 10
I haven't read anything so funny in ages. Shannon rocked Guy's ass off!?!?!?!
Shannon barely held it together. He is a mediocre karaoke singer at best. Sure he is a nice guy and deserves a break but he just cannot cut it.
To expand his appeal he could try opening his mouth when he talks and adding a few consonants into his vocabulary. Also sentences should not begin and end with the word "mate".
I thought for a brief moment during Working Class Man he was going to let go of his inhibitions and really let it rip but once again he pulled back and proved he just doesn't have what it takes. He's just a dude singing a song. Not in any way a performer.
Sure there are plenty of "entertainers" who have made it with less so there may be a niche for him...
But Guy deserves to win.
|
|
|
|
Post by Syrup on Nov 10, 2003 23:52:57 GMT 10
ophelia good evening/morning.
There is a niche for Shannon, the extent of his supporters reinforces this. The AI title however should not be based on unfortunate family/financial difficulties. It riles me up beyond belief when ppl do that.
If people want to show their sympathy or compassion, then they should go donate to the gazillion worthy charities or even donate to the Noll family directly (absolutely NO sarcasm intended). But please you guys, don't make this competition a bigger farce than it has already become. For those that truly like Shannon as a performer, go ahead and vote all you like. I don't have a problem with difference in opinion. For those that are sympathy vote inclined, don't do it. Give to charity instead and vote for who you believe to possess the most TALENT.
Sincerest best wishes to Shannon and his family, but GUY FOR IDOL.
|
|
|
|
Post by ophelia on Nov 10, 2003 23:58:17 GMT 10
 There's a thought. Save your $$$ and instead of SMS-ing "Shannon" 10 times send Shannon $5. Everybody wins.
|
|
|
|
Post by Syrup on Nov 11, 2003 0:07:54 GMT 10
LOL, thought you'd like something of mine eventually  |
|
|
|
Post by FLuffY SLippERs on Nov 11, 2003 8:06:51 GMT 10
shannon did better this week but guys done better before . theyve both had their nights . im over it i dont care who wins and i dont see why you guys are getting so cut up over it . both the final and runner up get the same contract with bmg the only diference being one is branded with the AI name . whatever happens theyre both gonna be releasing songs and selling records |
|
|
|
Post by shannons hot on Nov 11, 2003 9:39:49 GMT 10
|
|
|
|
Post by Liz on Nov 11, 2003 9:48:51 GMT 10
and ssssoooooo much out of tune too!
|
|
|
|
Post by bijy on Nov 11, 2003 12:22:53 GMT 10
anyone heard of individuality?? i think its unreal that there are two completely different idols up there in the final.. they both have their own style which will each appeal to different people.. respect others opinions and preferences, you dont need to bag out shan or guy just because you prefer the other one.. AI is a damn hard competition and to get to the end is fantastic for both of them.. also i find it amazing that people believe that guy is an r&b wanna be and can only sing one style.. true everyone has a different style but i think that guy has shown enormous versatility particularly with climb every mountain, i couldnt see 50 cent singing that one! hehehe can you imagine? well you never know do you?
|
|
|
|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 11, 2003 13:15:54 GMT 10
Most Shannon fans are going for him because of his looks . It's so freakin OBVIOUS!!!  |
|
There's a thought. Save your $$$ and instead of SMS-ing "Shannon" 10 times send Shannon $5. Everybody wins.
;D 
