mikkie
Back up Vocals
Music is the key to my salvation
Posts: 145
|
Post by mikkie on Oct 14, 2003 23:17:32 GMT 10
i agree his performance tonight on idol up close and personal was great he sang ronan keating's song excellent. Im not afraid to say tht i like him and no im not a teenybopper either i am just simply entertained by his performances. Personally i dont think he has the vocal talent in comparison to the likes of Guy and Paulini (who i hope are the last 2 standing) but i do like Mills and his style
|
|
|
Post by Shannon on Oct 14, 2003 23:18:59 GMT 10
Lets talk about Shannon.
|
|
|
Post by GoPaulini on Oct 15, 2003 9:50:45 GMT 10
Millsie is just another Scott Caine. Be lucky to get one hit and then fade to oblivion, never to be heard from again!!
Go Pauline
|
|
|
Post by Feli city on Oct 15, 2003 10:19:09 GMT 10
You know what bothers me about Mills? Is that he sings easy songs - great
whilst the others (or some of the others) and pushing themselves to sing hard songs, and somehow it's ok that Mills is even allowed to be in the same league as them...
See we all sing - whether or not we are good, and have you noticed that there are certain songs that are easier to sing than others, well thery're the sorts of songs Mills sings.
See I am no singer - and I can actually sing most of the songs Mills sings, and pull them off well, but if I try and sing some of guy's or paulini's song choices - it would be 'bye bye felicity' - cause I can't sing them..
So it pisses me off that mills egts away with it - and that's why people in the 'KNOW' like Dicko - said he sings songs for lazy buggers -
IT TOTALLY PISSES ME OFF!
|
|
|
Post by Feli city on Oct 15, 2003 10:22:31 GMT 10
oh -
and I think the fact is that most people like rob, even though he is an arrogant little sh*t - he's quite entertaining and a cutie!
BUT the problem is simply this.... that Rob is not worthy of a win, beside the likes of Paulini, he may deserve a record contract of sorts, but he doesn't deserve the winner's contract nor does he deserve to win. BUT there reason for the fuss is that He could WIN - purely on the basis - that MOST of his voters are voting because he is cute - and because they want his face on a poster on their wall so they can sit and dream about him in their pubescent fantasies!
(looks sadly I know cause if this show had been on 8 years ago - that would have been me - luckily I grew up and escaped that!)
|
|
|
Post by UGLYMILLS on Oct 15, 2003 11:00:30 GMT 10
i AM WILLING TO BET MY LIFE SAVINGS THAT:
IF ROBERT MILLS WAS AN UGLY F*** HE WOULD NOT BE IN THE POSITION HE IS TODAY.
SOMEONE NEEDS TO SMASH BASH AND CRASH THAT PRETTY BOY
|
|
|
Post by fairy78 on Oct 15, 2003 15:50:19 GMT 10
I don't think much of Millsie at all - you can not compare his voice to Guy, Paulini or Cosima - their voices are amazing and he is just good. The standard of his performances have been good but not great - whereas Guy, Paulini & Cosima have all had consistantly fantastic performances. He may work the camera and audience well - but when you buy his cd you won't be able to see him, so shouldn't the most important thing be their voice? I think millsie & shannon have to go, and leave it to be out of guy, paulini or cosima to win!
|
|
|
Post by Farting mills on Oct 15, 2003 15:52:14 GMT 10
Why don't you clowns drop dead - sticks and stones will break my bones but your nasty posts will never hurt me.
|
|
|
Post by fairy78 on Oct 15, 2003 15:59:52 GMT 10
i also agree that he has been choosing easy songs. Guy has chosen to perform songs by great musicians like Prince, Brian Adams and that guy who sung 'What a Wonderful World' - songs he chose because the originals were unbelievable and to perform them well means he is performing at a high level. Same goes for Paulini - with her song choices by great original artists like Aretha Franklin. And Cosima also choosing songs by fantastic musicians like Tina Turner & Whitney Houston. They are choosing songs of very high standard and performing them to a high standard - millsy and shannon cant really compete with that!
|
|