|
|
Post by James on Oct 7, 2003 21:33:56 GMT 10
I am so upset Kelly has been voted out. She was such a great performer and had a real gutsy voice. I don't think it's fair that Cosima is still in when Kellys votes bet her in the top 40 round finals their group of eight. Kelly has heaps more talent than Cosima and didnt need a makeova, altleast she has her own style.
|
|
|
|
Post by r u serious on Oct 7, 2003 21:44:25 GMT 10
listen to cosimas voice and then kellys voice cosimas voice is so much more powerful  u must be blind if u cant see that and as for the statement[Kelly has heaps more talent than Cosima and didnt need a makeova, altleast she has her own style. ] kelly needs a makeover !!! SKIRTS OVER PANTS WENT OUT IN THE 80S anyway kelly had an ok voice but cosima is heaps better and obviously the public agree as well  |
|
|
|
Post by yea i reckon on Oct 7, 2003 21:46:14 GMT 10
i agree kelly was out of her league noone wants a rock chick although she was good cosimas voice is way better its up there with paulinis saying cosimas out of her league is the same as saying paulini is and thats just a load of crap!
|
|
|
|
Post by James on Oct 8, 2003 0:43:31 GMT 10
A lot of people want a rock chic. This is why Kelly was voted through over Cosima in the first place. I think the whole notion of the wild card round sux. I f it wasn't for that my number one idol kelly would still be in it! Sirts over pants looks wicked and atleast Kel doesn't change her style from week to week.
|
|
|
|
Post by scoober steve on Oct 8, 2003 9:01:07 GMT 10
cosima has the same style every week if kelly was better than her then she would still be there wouldnt she and she was in tha bottom three every week and cosima always has top ratings and even if cosima wasnt there kelly still would have gone because not many ppl like that style anymore and she never get many votes
|
|
|
|
Post by champs on Oct 8, 2003 17:06:29 GMT 10
You can argue all day over who's better but at the end of the day they've all done fantastic to make it to the final 12. So I think there all pretty damn fine to make it that far. My favourite is out now but I'm not going to be dissing all the other contestants (cause there all extremely talented). Best wishes to all remaining idols!
|
|
|
|
Post by Mantastic Plastic on Oct 8, 2003 18:46:10 GMT 10
Cosima does change her style every week - but the truth is that Kelly sucks, and she shouldn't of made it in over Cosima, not to mention Rebecca T.
She was really good on 70s night, but her performance of Mascara was just awful.
|
|
|
|
Post by anastascia on Oct 8, 2003 20:29:56 GMT 10
cosima out of her league? not even kelly was ok but i agree she never should of beat rebecca tapia or cosima  |
|
|
|
Post by Shaztroy on Oct 9, 2003 18:23:02 GMT 10
You must be deaf if you think Kelly or any of the other contestants are/were better than Cosima! They're all brilliant performers, but Cosima leaves the rest of the pack for dead!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by jade on Oct 9, 2003 18:32:52 GMT 10
i agree with you! shaztroy!!! woo hoo!! Cosima rocks majorly. dont get me wrong i like kelly, but cosima moves me with her singing. I really am hoping shell make it far, not sureif shell win it, but i want her to get a record deal so i can buy her cd! Rebekah too! Again ill say it , COSIMA is sweet and she rocks !!! ;D
|
|
wottyatalkinaboutwillis
Guest
|
Post by wottyatalkinaboutwillis on Oct 11, 2003 11:46:45 GMT 10
cosima, paulini and guy are are the only three with genuine talent left TO CARRY THEM TO THE END (not saying that they other 12 didnt have any talent at all -- they all sing ALMOST as good i do i guess ) cosimas learning a lot, paulini is way ahead of wat AI is about anyway (why hasnt she already got a bunch of albums sitting in the record shops!??!) and guy ... hmmm well hard to compare with diva types but his voice is good ... tho im not sure id say 'versatile' ... it has too much of an individual 'wobble' |
|
|
|
Post by bonds babi on Oct 11, 2003 20:32:05 GMT 10
yea i fully agree kelly had talent but in a different way cosima appeals to more people as for the comment about cosima being out of her league ------->as if wat have u been listenin 2 the last few months |
|
lilly
Karaoke Singer
Posts: 75
|
Post by lilly on Oct 13, 2003 15:02:50 GMT 10
So you'd rather listen to a cow going through a shredder (Kelly) than a gal whose voice is close to flawless (Cosima)? Wow! I did have a soft spot for Kelly, I thought it would be cool if she continually got in the bottom 3 but made it through to the final. But she ain't no Courtney Love, & she lacked charisma. BOTH Cosima & Kelly have SERIOUS FASHION ISSUES - call for new stylists!
|
|
|
|
Post by FLuffY SLippERs on Oct 13, 2003 16:25:05 GMT 10
yea true and as for jamess comment that cosima changes her fashion every week - she does but who cares it got her higher than kelly . maybe kelly needed to change her outfit every week |
|
u must be blind if u cant see that and as for the statement[Kelly has heaps more talent than Cosima and didnt need a makeova, altleast she has her own style. ] kelly needs a makeover !!! SKIRTS OVER PANTS WENT OUT IN THE 80S anyway kelly had an ok voice but cosima is heaps better and obviously the public agree as well 
