|
Post by Mo on Apr 20, 2004 13:20:56 GMT 10
Fantasia ;D ;D ;D
|
|
|
Post by barbs007 on Apr 22, 2004 23:25:36 GMT 10
too hard!!
|
|
|
Post by Edster on Apr 23, 2004 0:43:28 GMT 10
Latoya is my choice. More classy.
|
|
|
Post by Guest on Apr 27, 2004 14:19:26 GMT 10
I think the Fantasia vs La Toya choice is similar to the Guy vs Paulini choice on Australian Idol.
Paulini, like La Toya, sang everything perfectly as it should be sung. She didn't make any substancial mistakes and was always at a very high standard. Whereas Guy, like Fantasia is a little different. They are both "edgier" and funkier and offer an alternative to what you hear all of the time.
The first time I heard Fantasia, which was in the first heat of the top 32 I thought she would be the winner, irrespective of the quality of the remaining contestants. Based on what I've heard so far I haven't changed my mind. I think she is the best contestant I have ever heard on this type of show.
She should be an easy winner.
|
|
|
Post by PyroDeity on Apr 27, 2004 19:53:02 GMT 10
FANTASIA
|
|
|
Post by Monkey on Apr 27, 2004 21:46:35 GMT 10
You are right guest the more I see Fantastia the more impressed I become with her. She takes big risks like Guy did, and is definitely an original in the way she performs and in her song choices.
I think Latoya and Fantasia are both amazingly talented, but if I was to buy only one album I would buy LaToya.
|
|
|
Post by another guest on May 1, 2004 17:04:49 GMT 10
Fantasia for me... if you are doing a poll thing...
|
|
|
Post by family5 on May 2, 2004 22:05:43 GMT 10
Fantasia's attitude is starting to irritate me.
Latoya's lack of it was irritating me but now I'm with Edster... she is more classy.
So.....
LATOYA.
Also... I agree mostly with 'Guest's comparison of Paulini and La Toya, and Guy and Fantasia; however for me that is where it ends. Guy and Fantasia could be described as "edgier" and "funkier" and "offer an alternative to what you hear all of the time" BUT Guy does it all with humility, good grace and natural charisma. To me Fantasia lacks said humility and there is something about her that grates on me more each week.
|
|
|
Post by southernaurora on May 3, 2004 13:20:16 GMT 10
Fantasia - is so cool - has great personality - and as far as the comments go about her so called 'attitude' I like her spunk! Whats wrong with having a bit of confidence in yourself? Shes a fun person with a great voice and is a funky mama. (ps We Aussies need to avoid catching the tall poppie syndrome)
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on May 3, 2004 14:41:04 GMT 10
i like them both the same atm. but A13 idol is boring me and ive decided not to watch anymore. unless of course JPL is on it ;D
|
|
|
Post by Elle on May 17, 2004 0:54:10 GMT 10
Fantasia SHOULD win , but who knows after watching the way America votes.
|
|
|
Post by frogo on May 17, 2004 0:59:17 GMT 10
I agree - it's become boring except for FANTASIA!!! I loooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooove her! Imagine Fantasia and Guy doing a duet!! Ho! Ho!
|
|
|
Post by Elle on May 17, 2004 1:14:09 GMT 10
Yes please, frogo - I'm SURE now Guy will be singing next week.
I saw Clay sing on American idol for the for time tonight - while he has a good voice, have to admit he doesn't hold my attention, I was reading a booking half way through the song.
That just doesn't happen when Guy sings........not that I am interested in comparing the 2, they both have their individual giftings.
|
|
|
Post by guest on May 17, 2004 1:15:40 GMT 10
Always loved fantasia's voice, but only really liked her as a person when they told george to join the top group. fantasia was very quick to laugh when she realised thay'd been tricked, she saw the funny side. I like that. ;D
|
|
|
Post by regieunlogged on May 17, 2004 8:57:49 GMT 10
Hey Elle,
I keep hearing that Guy is gonna be on American Idol 3. Who said that? Wouldn't they have said something on the show by now?? Would be a treat though.
And Clay's voice was a BIG yawn. Wasn't excited at all.
Finger's crossed that Guy will be one!! He'll just blow everybody away. What a treat that will be!!!! America hasn't really been exposed to any Oz singers recently...except the lovely Kylie. And I think maybe one other guy...can't think of his name. Opps. Will be great. Go Da Fro!!! WooWooo!!!!
|
|