|
Post by LEIGH on Nov 10, 2003 16:28:42 GMT 10
I'm like whatever GUY WAS THE BEST!!!!! GO GUY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Guy's song made me cry I'm listening to it right now, and i had played it for like 25 times already.... I LOVE GUY!!!
|
|
|
Post by meghan lee on Nov 10, 2003 16:52:16 GMT 10
I thought the song was okay, but probably not a single I would normally buy. However after seeing Shannon perform it last night I have decided if he wins I would be down the shops the next morning buying it. The song was just made for Shannon and that showed in the heart-felt/me TEXT performance he gave. I used to be a Guy fan but now its Shannon all the way. /me TEXTTEXT
|
|
|
Post by jaime on Nov 10, 2003 16:55:47 GMT 10
I thought the song was okay, but probably not a single I would normally buy. However after seeing Shannon perform it last night I have decided if he wins I would be down the shops the next morning buying it. The song was just made for Shannon and that showed in the heart-felt performance he gave. I used to be a Guy fan but now its Shannon all the way. [glow=red,2,300]TEXT[/glow]SHANNON ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! TEXTTEXT
|
|
LISA
Shower Crooner
Posts: 0
|
Post by LISA on Nov 10, 2003 16:57:36 GMT 10
after seeing Shannon perform it last night I have decided if he wins I would be down the shops the next morning buying it. The song was just made for Shannon and that showed in the heart-felt/me TEXT performance he gave. SHANNON TO WIN ;D TEXTTEXT
|
|
|
Post by rooooar on Nov 10, 2003 17:17:16 GMT 10
lisa needs a job.........and a life
|
|
|
Post by sink on Nov 10, 2003 17:36:25 GMT 10
yep the song was pretty crap...seems like the trend amongst idol shows that the first single they release is a sappy ballad (have u heard kelly clarkson's 1st single release in the US? it's also pretty crap!)
as much as i love guy i reckon shannon's version was better...
i thought crazy in love was a mistake when he said he was picking it, but he managed to salvage it I guess. At least he's done different-ish stuff, unlike Shannon who is Barnsey II all the way...
|
|
|
Post by FLuffY SLippERs on Nov 11, 2003 8:16:36 GMT 10
just because she has a different opinion 2 u doesnt mean she needs a life and a job. get over your immaturity
|
|
|
Post by Diva on Nov 11, 2003 9:03:10 GMT 10
I think the song sucked for both of them and nothing they were going to do was going to make it a brilliant song! Guy's version was good but even he couldn't ressurrect it! Shannon's version is beautiful, but he strained in the high notes and the production of the song was quite laboured. It was R&B from Guy & smooth country from Shannon. neither of the versions were brilliant. It was written by Mark who is no real talent and it sounded like a Vanessa Amarosi reject song!
|
|
bee
Shower Crooner
Posts: 0
|
Post by bee on Nov 11, 2003 9:06:55 GMT 10
i thought that the angel song was totally crap - nothing against the guys but if these are the sorts of songs we can expect our idol to be singing then i certainly wont be buying the album. What is Dicko thinking. I mean hes in marketing surely he would have forseen that the song is crap and they ridicule contestants for their song choice.
the song is such a Cosima ballad
isn't it funny how there was an article in the paper saying that shannon and guy had sore throats and colds, but the public thought that was okay, where as cosima has throat nodules and throat infections and the public ridiculed her.
|
|
|
Post by bijy on Nov 11, 2003 11:56:39 GMT 10
i loved the song and i love both guy and shannon, i am so happy to see two really great genuine guys up there and i would be happy for either of them to be the australian idol.. i was so impressed with shannons performances as well, i think he would have done himself, his family and his fans proud and he showed that he really does deserve to be up there in the final.. i love guy but i did really love shannons version of angels brought me here, it really moved me.. poor guy being so sick, i hope he gets well soon.. what a competition, how exciting!
|
|
|
Post by *Melinda* =) on Nov 11, 2003 14:51:12 GMT 10
GUYS VERSION WAS THE BEST!!!!
|
|
|
Post by Tara on Nov 11, 2003 16:19:52 GMT 10
Excuse me but it's Shannon who sticks to the same kind of songs all the time. He doesn't have variety at all...they pretty much all sound the same. He only does well because he picks the same sort of songs all the time that he knows he can sing. As for Guy he can sing just about any song and make it awesome. Guy is the most talented person in the show. Even Dicko said that Guy had the best unsigned voice/talent he had ever heard. Even though Shannon sung really well on Sunday night I would not want him to be australian idol because as I said before, he can't sing a great variety of songs. I mean who would buy Shannon's cd - it would be pretty boring. Do you really think he could make it far when he's up against P Diddy and so fourth. That's where Guy comes in - he's original and really does have one of the greatest voices I have ever heard. That's why I reckon everyone should - VOTE FOR GUY!!!!!!!!! Because he would be a real shame if Shannon won.
|
|
|
Post by *Melinda* =) on Nov 11, 2003 16:47:34 GMT 10
Couldn't have said it better myself Tara.
|
|
|
Post by whoami on Nov 11, 2003 22:28:59 GMT 10
The song was crap!
But, I gotta say Shannons version was better (but still crap).
Having said that, I must say I am a Shannon fan and have been for weeks. He sings great aussie rock and he's typical Aussie battler, what else do you want in an Aussie Idol.
Some of the arguments I've seen on this board about who would do better on the world stage have it all wrong. Put Guy on the world stage and everyone will say "where was he from again???". Whereas if you put Shannon out there everyone will instantly recognise that Aussie style.
|
|
|
Post by *¨^¨JESS ¨^¨* on Nov 11, 2003 23:00:57 GMT 10
If Shannon manages to win this competition I will be cringeing with embarrassment for him, knowing he will have to compete on the world stage. I'm sure he is a nice person, a typical Aussie (I suppose that means white?) but he is very limited in the type of songs he can sing. Also, his voice fades away in the lower registers and he can only reach the top notes if he shouts. Guy, by comparison, is a true professional already and his voice is amazing. He also knows how to entertain.
|
|