|
Post by guyfannn on Dec 8, 2003 6:23:26 GMT 10
here's why i think kelly will win besides her talent:
-she's already a household name in many countries - only one song will be sung so this a disadvantage for guy coz the overseas audience don't know guy and you have to get to know him before you love him...i bet most of yous weren't going for guy even after he sang his first song wonderful world and only jumped on the bandwaggon mid-way through the show - kelly has better form than guy...she never got voted in the bottom in american idol
|
|
|
Post by aKa..Levi_LoVeR on Dec 10, 2003 23:35:02 GMT 10
that sort of depends on the individual. i feel in love with Guy back at the Seymour Centre i think it was when he performed with shannon and costa in the group of 3. but it is true u do need tym to grow and love him. i also loved Rebekah and Levi and still do to thiss day but i guess u do need abit of time to really realize Guy's potential. hopefully people will realize this from the beginning and vote for him but its very true that Kelly Clarkson has a big big advantage becoz she's had so much publicity around the world.althoug being the newest idol Guy is at his best to being equal 1st to take out the title of world idol against kelly. if the rest of the world love him like we do he will have a very good chance... GUY ALL THE WAY...HE ROCKS
|
|
|
Post by quickie on Dec 10, 2003 23:49:18 GMT 10
First of all, Guyfannn, you are a complete tool!
Kelly might b ea houshold name in a few countries, but that doesnt mean they all think she's geat. They might not even like her, so thats a stupid comment.
You have to get to know Guy before you like him? I might be wrong here, but WI isnt like some beauty contest showcasing women who want world peace. Its a show about singing, which I'm pretty sure Guy will be able to handle.
Kelly never got voted in the bottom three? Are you serious? Because if thats true, then its rock solid proof that shes gonna walk away with the title...
PFFFTTTT!
Give us a break. Guy will have just as much chance as kelly, and it will come down to how they both perform. Sure, Kelly might have an edge, but Guy will give her a run for her money... she could probably use it...
|
|
|
Post by quickie on Dec 10, 2003 23:55:18 GMT 10
Just thaught you might like to know, that Kelly's single is currently sitting at 57 (and falling) on the UK charts after just three weeks.
Yep, theres that huuuuge fan base again
|
|
|
Post by Chicagoholic on Dec 11, 2003 0:00:17 GMT 10
I think that Australian Idol had the best talent with regards to their singers. Kelly Clarkson was never in the bottom 2/3..but what were the people competing against her like? Be honest, if Kelly was up against the likes of Paulini, Cosima, Bek, Shannon etc do you think that perhaps she would've been in the bottom 2/3 as well?
|
|
|
Post by guyfannn on Dec 12, 2003 12:36:36 GMT 10
what is the popluation of America? what is the popluation of Australia? you do the maths
|
|
|
Post by Pseudo Bohemian Goddess on Dec 12, 2003 12:47:41 GMT 10
And i bet that is the main reason why you can't vote for your own country.
|
|
|
Post by meh on Dec 13, 2003 11:49:00 GMT 10
Kelly is good but I don't think she is great
|
|
|
Post by Ashleigh on Dec 13, 2003 13:52:39 GMT 10
firstly quickie, you are totally right, ;D who cares if she's a household name? Once they see Guy's AMAZING talent in even ONE song ('cos come on, guy can easily prove himself in one song) he'll have a serious chance and also i agree that if kelly clarkson was against the likes of paulini, bec, cosima and shannon, let alone guy she'd have a run for her money so i reckon guy is simply gonna ROCK world idol and show 'em what aussies are made of.
|
|
|
Post by Ashleigh on Dec 13, 2003 13:53:51 GMT 10
firstly quickie, you are totally right, who cares if she's a household name? Once they see Guy's AMAZING talent in even ONE song ('cos come on, guy can easily prove himself in one song) he'll have a serious chance and also i agree that if kelly clarkson was against the likes og paulini, bec, cosima and shannon, let alone guy she'd have a run for her money so i reckon guy is simply gonna ROCK world idol and show 'em what aussies are made of.oh and has anyone actually REALISED the voting conditions, countries aren't allowed to vote for their idol, 'cos if they were kelly clarkson would be the winner no doubts.
|
|
|
Post by guyfannn on Dec 13, 2003 14:30:05 GMT 10
I'm saying that ameria has about 20 times the population of australia so there must have been over 20 times more american contestants than there are australian contestants. So to win american idol is far harder than to win Australian Idol. Most of the top 40 Australian Idol would not have even made it to the top 40 over there. No way would Millsy pass the first round of auditions. I've seen American Idol, and the contestant's talent is on a higher class...but I still think Guy will come like second.
|
|
|
Post by Pseudo Bohemian Goddess on Dec 13, 2003 15:59:34 GMT 10
oh, I thought you were referring to world idol.
I like Kelly but Rueben's voice doesn't really do it for me. I'll guess I'll have to wait for the 3rd American Idol and see what kinda talent they have.
|
|
|
Post by Chicagoholic on Dec 13, 2003 22:24:35 GMT 10
"I'm saying that ameria has about 20 times the population of australia so there must have been over 20 times more american contestants than there are australian contestants. So to win american idol is far harder than to win Australian Idol"
From opinions on the World Idol boards, many think that Australian Idol had the most talented group of performers. So that would make it harder to win Australian Idol, wouldn't it?
|
|
|
Post by GuyToWin on Dec 14, 2003 0:37:33 GMT 10
i agree that if kelly clarkson was against the likes of paulini, bec, cosima and shannon, let alone guy she'd have a run for her money quote] A big fan of Guy but Kelly is a much better singer than Bec and Shannon. Bec couldn't keep up with the rest of them, she was sick but so was some other contestants, Bec never managed to keep raising the bar like Guy, Paulini and Cosima in the comp. Bec is too mournful for me.
|
|
|
Post by guyfannn on Dec 14, 2003 17:23:23 GMT 10
' From opinions on the World Idol boards, many think that Australian Idol had the most talented group of performers."
This board is dominated by Australians, so I think its a bit bias.
|
|