|
|
Post by Ava on Apr 4, 2004 23:13:44 GMT 10
i missed it unfortunately...but i caught the group performance on the results show...does anyone else think the dancing is a bit dad-daggy?
the hand actions *in the air!*
it wasn't that great, but i noticed latoya is a superb performer, she's definitely got the moves
...but i missed the aussie idol group version of ain't no mountain high enough...and guy's funky spins
*runs off to watch it*
ahhhh ;D
|
|
|
|
Post by random on Apr 4, 2004 23:26:22 GMT 10
The only performances I really enjoyed were Fantasias and Georges...Jasmine and Latoya were also OK. Everyone else was bor-ing! Even my fave Jon-Peter. The worst performance was John Stevens! Generally I am a fan of his...but this week, geez!  Camille was also pretty darn terrible. I don't think any of the bottom 3 really deserved to be there, although I was glad Jennifer was...she just irks me so much. She is good, but in a really annoying way! |
|
|
|
Post by Ava on Apr 4, 2004 23:48:15 GMT 10
im just watching the performances now...
i still luv camille, shes got something about her (but i choose to listen to the mp3 over the vid) - she's got the 'bek' quality - so she's ace in my books!
jennifer i don't mind anymore...i thought she didn't belong in the finals at first, but she performed the song great tonight
and i still can't get over diana's age...she's amazing at 16! and nice to see matt again in the audience - all the funny people are getting booted!
|
|
|
|
Post by teetree on Apr 4, 2004 23:50:40 GMT 10
Everyone else was bor-ing! Even my fave Jon-Peter. The worst performance was John Stevens! Generally I am a fan of his...but this week, geez! I can agree with you that John Stevens really stank!!! I felt so bad for him |
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on Apr 4, 2004 23:55:25 GMT 10
i thought JPL performance was pretty good...or was that because i had listined to the Mp3 so many times that i new it off by heart and could sing along |
|
Ajj
Shower Crooner
Posts: 19
|
Post by Ajj on Apr 5, 2004 3:06:26 GMT 10
i still luv camille, shes got something about her (but i choose to listen to the mp3 over the vid) - she's got the 'bek' quality - so she's ace in my books! That's kind of the problem though. Like Bek, she's pretty and charismatic but not really a great singer/performer. I really think it's time for Camille to go, especially if she doesn't improve on her last 3 performances. Simon said that Jennifer was out of her depth, but I think that applies more to Camille. |
|
|
|
Post by PyroDeity on Apr 5, 2004 8:16:52 GMT 10
I can agree with you that John Stevens really stank!!! I felt so bad for him  but then again he could just sit there blowing spit bubbles and i'd find it wonderful |
|
|
|
Post by Monkey on Apr 5, 2004 10:03:12 GMT 10
I have to say that I expected John Stevens to go this week too, the song just didn't suit his voice.
|
|
|
|
Post by superc on Apr 5, 2004 10:30:10 GMT 10
My major impression was that the band was too loud and drowned out all the singers. Top performers - Fantasia and George. Fantasia was a little distracting tottering around the stage on those heels and I didn't understand George's dishcloth... but they were both wonderful  The bottom two for me - Camile (even though I love her!) and John Stevens (the theme was just wrong for him). I'm not surprised that LaToya and Amy were in the bottom three... LaToya's song was a little boring while Amy's was lacking in the bubbly energy she usually exhibits. Both were quite lacklustre. I think it's all due to the loudness of the band... they were basically all shouting to hear themselves, except George, who has a powerful voice. |
|
|
|
Post by Maddyn on Apr 5, 2004 13:27:32 GMT 10
i thought JPL performance was pretty good...or was that because i had listined to the Mp3 so many times that i new it off by heart and could sing along I thought it was good too. And I liked his country song last week, but the judges were lukewarm at best |
|
|
|
Post by Reggietheyank on Apr 5, 2004 20:13:55 GMT 10
Superc: Alot of the Old Time Black American singers used to do the clothe thingy. So it was a take on that! I loved Latoya's performance. She has such a powerful voice. The fact that she could take it down a notch or two AND control it...well it was awesome!! I liked JPL's performance. Enjoyed it very much. Just DO NOT get the Camille thing. The girl just can't sing at all. Don't get why she is still there. The red headed dude. HELLO!! Why was he not in the bottom three?? Has a nice voice. But THAT performance just really sucked BIG time. Fantasia still rubs me the wrong way but she is talented. Smiling George was great. Old school ALL THE WAY!!!! Jennifer's performance was good. She has attitude though. Basically, I think Latoya should win...she is talented, classy and beautiful. |
|
|
|
Post by hellcat on Apr 5, 2004 21:14:45 GMT 10
Brilliant:
Fantasia
George
Very Good
Latoya
Jasmine
Jennifer
Diane
OK
Amy
Crap
JPL
Camille
John
|
|
|
|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Apr 5, 2004 22:04:39 GMT 10
JPL crap? No way he is never crap! Last nite wasn't my favourite of his performances but he was still awesum! However, my fave performance was Diana omg she is so fantastic! I don't feel like she gets enough recognition for wat she does. She's so entertaining and her voice is wonderful! I have immensely enjoyed all of her performances so far, particularly "Think" and last nite's "Do you love me" I also liked LaToya's. I'm not really a fan of hers, simply because while she seems like a really nice person, personality wise she really just doesn't appeal to me. I think maybe that's part of the reason Ima HUGE fan of JPL, but also because he has this awesum unique voice. And while I feel that Latoya has a really strong voice and gives practically flawless performances every time, there really isn't anything all that unique bout her. I really enjoyed her performance last nite tho. Not surprised Amy left, she used to really impress me but now it's like since being in the finals she's lost a lot of her spunk in her performances which is really sad. I really love Camille her voice is just fantastic, so different to all the otha gurls, she has a Mariah Carey feel going on with it. However, I feel that her performances have been seriously lacking as compared to wat I have seen her do previously. I keep feeling that all of a sudden she's gonna break out and do sumthing BEAUTIFUL... I just hope she does it soon before everyone gives up on her.  Her performance last nite was quite good, very funky, only complaint was that I could barely hear her over the band. |
|
|
|
Post by hellcat on Apr 5, 2004 22:08:22 GMT 10
JPL crap? No way he is never crap! He's always crap |
|
|
|
Post by lethbridge forever on Apr 5, 2004 22:19:42 GMT 10
JPL is out of his depth. Jon Stevens... well you talk about 'star quality' where is that factor in him? No way could I ever see this guy performing in sold out arena's across the country, he seems very average. And My Girl proved that he's a one trick pony.
I think Camille is great, but she's so awkward to watch now. Whether she's got that mic pole infront of her, or sits on a stool or moves around you just have this Lauren Buckley feel about her where you feel sorry that she's just had a shocker. I love her voice though, might not be huge but it's very different.
Simon always seems to be on the money about performances, would've loved to hear him finish off his sentence about Camille when commenting on Jon Stevens 'abysmal' performance.
George Huff looks like atleast top 2 material. Most people seem to rate him over Ruben, the other top 2 person will probably be Fantasia. But Macy Gray doesn't sell records anymore.......
By the way, how the hell did Ruben win American Idol 2? His song "Sorry 2k4" is very average, and he has "boring" written all over him. I love the bit in the song where he rips on the high notes, but when he performed 2k4 on the show, he couldn't hit any.
|
|
Camille was also pretty darn terrible.
Her performance last nite was quite good, very funky, only complaint was that I could barely hear her over the band.