|
Post by Mo on Apr 1, 2004 11:08:03 GMT 10
1. La Toya because both her up tempo songs and ballads have been extremely well done. She seems the most professional of the lot. 2. Fantasia because she's unique and is a great performer. I did have a problem with her attitude, but I'm starting to think her attitude isnt "I'm better than everyone else" more that she has confidence in herself. Besides at least she isn't being fake. I 3. I'm torn between Diana and George. I love George's personality but I also love Diana's voice. I think the chances of a girl winning American Idol 3 this year and really high. have to agree with you there on your choices, but maybe I would put Fantasia first as LaToya is a bit screechy for me. But I would put her second because of her proffessionalism and her high standard comapared to some of the others. Love George and diana, they are both very cute. I was hoping Camille would do well, but she has been very dissapointing so far, maybe a bit too young and inexperienced. She hasn't sang as well as she did in the auditons.
|
|
|
Post by Chicagoholic on Apr 1, 2004 13:49:13 GMT 10
You know whats happened with me? I downloaded the performances and I'm now firmly in the Fantasia camp. I simply love "Always on My Mind"
So Fantasia is now clearly in the top spot for me, with LaToya second.
|
|
trish
Back up Vocals
but i am what i am, and all i want is freedom
Posts: 117
|
Post by trish on Apr 1, 2004 21:17:02 GMT 10
hmm thats definately tough to call at the moment...
singing-wise, i think latoya, diana and george are all very talented and will do well BUT my favourites are definately JPL - i LOVE him haha hes so hilarious and cute George - oh my god have you ever seen such a gorgeous smile! hehe he makes me smile just by looking at him and boy he can sing John Stevens - i've been a fan since the beginning, i looove his voice but i think he really needs to become more confident and a stronger singer to do well
oh and Simon Cowell of course... hehe
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on Apr 2, 2004 23:32:04 GMT 10
You know whats happened with me? I downloaded the performances and I'm now firmly in the Fantasia camp. I simply love "Always on My Mind" So Fantasia is now clearly in the top spot for me, with LaToya second. i really like fantasia now 2 !! after really sitting down and listing watching her performances a couple of times i was like wow! so my top 3 are now 1. JPL 2. Fantasia 3. Camile and John stevens
|
|
|
Post by Edster on Apr 9, 2004 12:30:29 GMT 10
I like George and Latoya. George for his great powerful and unique voice. I am just waiting for him to sing a ballad to really show his versatility. Latoya, she is just a polished performer but she does'nt have that X factor. I hope I'm wrong. The same thing happened to Paulini.
|
|
|
Post by random on Apr 9, 2004 22:07:46 GMT 10
Latoya, she is just a polished performer but she does'nt have that X factor. I hope I'm wrong. The same thing happened to Paulini. I agree, Latoya is just like Paulini. Everyone generally thinks she's great and no one seems to really dislike her, but people aren't getting attached to her personality. My fave is and will always be JPL, just because he is fun and different. But in terms of talent and performance, I think George Huff is the best. Fantasia might have appealed to me more if it weren't for that annoying attitude.
|
|
|
Post by superc on Apr 9, 2004 22:51:12 GMT 10
I think that George and Jennifer actually have the best voices in the competition (you can tell I go for deep, rich voices!). But Jennifer is not a good performer while George is. Fantasia is my girl now... goooo Fantasia! I think she's being funny, but rubs most people the wrong way. I like LaToya though... I loved how she said "It's a beautiful cat" in reply to Simon's yammering about her hair. She needs more of that kind of stuff
|
|
|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Apr 9, 2004 22:55:29 GMT 10
1. JPL - I am SO IN LOVE WITH HIM!!!! and have been since his audition I'm practically obsessed just ask my mum! I am soooo anxious every week to see his performances and hes gorgeous, hilarious, extremely entertaining and he has one of the most unusual voices I have ever heard ;D
2. Diana - She is so young but so talented. Her performances are really fun, just like Jon-Peter's! ;D
3. George - He's soooo sweet and funny! He always looks so happy to be there, performing for everyone. I really admire that he just seems so thankful to everyone who votes to keep him there. If he is signed I think he would be fantastic to his fans. ;D
|
|
|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Apr 9, 2004 22:58:30 GMT 10
Oh also, I absolutely love Camille's voice when she sang "One Last Cry" I was so touched she sounded so much like Mariah Carey. Unfortunately since being in the finals she just hasn't kept up the standards she had already set for herself which is unfortunate. She used to be one of my faves but now that she's out ( ) its definetely the above 3
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Apr 10, 2004 14:11:08 GMT 10
My top 3 are (in no particular order)
Jasmine, Diana and Latoya.
I'm not attached to any of the contestants yet but those three have done well.
|
|
|
Post by SoCrazyInLoveWithGUY on Apr 10, 2004 14:44:47 GMT 10
So many good singers!
Either Fantasia or George for No 1 - can't decide.
Then either Diana or Latoya for third.
|
|
|
Post by superc on Apr 10, 2004 21:01:48 GMT 10
I'm not attached to any of the contestants yet but those three have done well. I'm hopelessly attached to Camile and George. Note to self: stop being obsessive about TV show. But it's so fun! ;D There's been rumours flying around that Camile has been approached by Babyface! Admittedly Babyface is kind of in the past (his last big hit was ]"When can I see you again" (click here for a sample to jog your memory)- a beautiful song), but having him on your side cannot hurt at all. Go Camile! ;D
|
|
|
Post by morgana on Apr 10, 2004 21:38:15 GMT 10
Mine would have to be: 1. George Huff - great voice, great presence... 2. Fantasia - just so talented, although a bit much at times... 3. La Toya or Jasmine - probably La Toya these days, as although Jasmine was outstanding at first, she's slipped at bit into the mediocre I think...?
|
|
|
Post by superc on Apr 10, 2004 21:47:32 GMT 10
Mine would have to be: 1. George Huff - great voice, great presence... 2. Fantasia - just so talented, although a bit much at times... 3. La Toya or Jasmine - probably La Toya these days, as although Jasmine was outstanding at first, she's slipped at bit into the mediocre I think...? I think you've got my list by mistake! ;D
|
|
|
Post by Ava on Apr 11, 2004 2:28:09 GMT 10
There's been rumours flying around that Camile has been approached by Babyface! ...but having him on your side cannot hurt at all. Go Camile! ;D yay!!! with babyface on your side, its almost a guarranteed hit! gooooooooo Camille!
|
|