|
Post by Genotype on Mar 23, 2004 0:34:18 GMT 10
After watching American Idol I got this to say: I miss the Aus Idol Judges. Dicko is very articulate and witty....much better than Simon in my opinion. Also I find that Dicko actually CARES for the singers whereas Simon.... Randy is okay...but I prefer Mark. I know I know. Don't laugh. I just thought Mark was funny. He was the type of person who you would watch to see what the next "Stupid" thing he said. You know...we all LOVE to HATE him.
|
|
|
Post by Pseudo Bohemian Goddess on Mar 23, 2004 0:49:17 GMT 10
Randy and Simon are just so repetitive.
Even i could pull better stuff outta my ass then what they've said so far.
|
|
|
Post by Yada Yada Yada on Mar 23, 2004 0:49:44 GMT 10
Randy and Mark are both on the same wavelength. Idiotic, limited + incomprehensible vocab and inadequecy in their judging.
I prefer Marcia over Paula though. Paula's comments are wayyy repetitive and she's biased towards hot young male contestants (kinda flirts with them and gets flattered/swayed easily).
I ADORE Dicko and Simon <3
|
|
|
Post by Ava on Mar 23, 2004 1:25:14 GMT 10
i miss them too...how i long for fresh material!!!
the number of times i've heard:
- i love the tone of your voice - sorry *dead face* - booooo (from audience)
is reaching overkill
Bring back Dicko and Mark!!
|
|
|
Post by Arwen on Mar 23, 2004 1:27:21 GMT 10
Me too... i especially miss dicko i thought mark wasnt coming bak?
|
|
|
Post by Sunflower on Mar 23, 2004 11:45:11 GMT 10
I agree, our judges were soooo much better!
|
|
|
Post by Pinkline Jones on Mar 23, 2004 14:25:30 GMT 10
Our judges were pretty good but really Marcia (as nice as she is) didn't really provide much criticism where it was truly warranted. She should have said "Mills you're crap", "Shannon - ummm I'm sure you're a nice bloke but maybe Condoblin RSL is the ultimate venue for you". "Lauren - you provided me with some of the best laughs I've had for a while"
|
|
|
Post by Sailor Earth on Mar 23, 2004 14:31:25 GMT 10
Our judges were pretty good but really Marcia (as nice as she is) didn't really provide much criticism where it was truly warranted. She should have said "Mills you're crap", "Shannon - ummm I'm sure you're a nice bloke but maybe Condoblin RSL is the ultimate venue for you". "Lauren - you provided me with some of the best laughs I've had for a while" LOL! She probably wanted to be a bit more tactful But yeah... I haven't watched much of American Idol 3 but what I have seen of the judges... *yawn*... Simon's just nasty mean instead of having constructive criticism to say like Dicko always does... And Randy... jeez... how did he get to be a judge? He doesn't have much to add really...
|
|
Fyrrn
Shower Crooner
Codename:Shrapnel
Posts: 30
|
Post by Fyrrn on Mar 23, 2004 17:24:26 GMT 10
I think we're missing the Australia judges because they're Australian - like we're on the same wavelength as them.I agree that Paula is a bit repetitive - how much of Simon's meanness do you think is due to trying to say as much as he can in a short period of time? He sounded rushed to me in the last show. Randy's Americanisms sound a bit strange to me but I guess I'll get used to them. Y'know, I'm generalising here, but we've got a different sense of humour and I think we're a bit more straightforward than Americans are.
|
|
Fyrrn
Shower Crooner
Codename:Shrapnel
Posts: 30
|
Post by Fyrrn on Mar 23, 2004 19:52:15 GMT 10
BTW - did anyone else notice Simon playing with Paula's hair during the results show? What was THAT about?
|
|
|
Post by superc on Mar 23, 2004 22:16:41 GMT 10
BTW - did anyone else notice Simon playing with Paula's hair during the results show? What was THAT about? They're getting all cuddly and poor Randy's getting no lovin'. But it's cool, he's down with it. I like Randy actually cause he likes the same singers as I do . Simon makes alot of sense and articulates what everybody's thinking, but I wish he'd be either funny or less abrupt about it.
|
|
|
Post by Sailor Earth on Mar 23, 2004 23:16:43 GMT 10
BTW - did anyone else notice Simon playing with Paula's hair during the results show? What was THAT about? LOL yeah I noticed that too...
|
|
|
Post by SlackA on Mar 24, 2004 10:43:03 GMT 10
i think paula is crap...shes overly nice..and simon is just trying to live up to his stupid mean-he-bitch reputation..but i say out of the 3..he is the most honest.
randy..is just too much dawgin mang~
|
|
|
Post by Bel1234 on Mar 26, 2004 23:39:09 GMT 10
I actually like all 3 judges. i think simon's cool. i actually think he talks alot of sense, and i tend to agree with most things he says!
Bella
|
|
|
Post by JustinGuariniFan on Mar 28, 2004 21:03:48 GMT 10
You guys do Realise that 99% of Mark Holdens Lines are stolen from the judges in US Idol 1 and 2.
Even "His" TOUCHDOWNline is stolen form Paula Adbul
.....Yes Thats Right. Paula Has Been Chearleading since day one in US Idol which funnily enough includes a TOUCHDOWN salute when a performer brings down the house..
You may also notice in US Idol 3 on the couple of occasions Paula has jumped up for a bit of cheerleading it has been crudley deited by channel TEN in an effort to protect Mark Holdens (little) credibility.
|
|