|
Post by SlackA on Feb 10, 2004 4:12:36 GMT 10
i thought nicole (scooter girl) was good. i dont understand what they mean when they saud she wasnt being consistent??
its like whatever she does is wrong.. she has a good voice..she has a good personality. judges gave her advice comment..she worked on it.
it seems like nothing pleases them..
so i say..she shld coem back for the wildcard
and yeah..briana was never shown..but so was most of the others too..but doesnt mean that they sucked just coz the auditions wasnt shown.
im happy with the same pple yada yada mentioned! well..jonah isnt thattt great tho
|
|
|
Post by Yada Yada Yada on Feb 10, 2004 8:16:51 GMT 10
i thought nicole (scooter girl) was good. i dont understand what they mean when they saud she wasnt being consistent?? its like whatever she does is wrong.. she has a good voice..she has a good personality. judges gave her advice comment..she worked on it. it seems like nothing pleases them.. so i say..she shld coem back for the wildcard and yeah..briana was never shown..but so was most of the others too..but doesnt mean that they sucked just coz the auditions wasnt shown. im happy with the same pple yada yada mentioned! well..jonah isnt thattt great tho Scooter-girl has a really good voice, true - but i have to go with what the judges said, she's very 'Broadway' - in terms of the style of her voice. I think her voice is perfect for musicals - but not as a pop singer/idol.
|
|
|
Post by superc on Feb 10, 2004 8:45:05 GMT 10
I'm pretty sure some of them are there just for the ratings- Lisa W being the prime example. I like Camile and Jonah (can't beat the Hawaiians!) Jonah's voice isn't that great, but he's got presence . I also like Amy and Erskine. I like Bri and Jennifer's personalities. Scooter girl's voice was all wrong for pop... I think that's the main reason she was booted out, rather than being too boring (lots of them were pretty boring!) Oooh, and bring on the Noel vs Jesus thing! ;D
|
|
|
Post by Chicagoholic on Feb 10, 2004 11:49:49 GMT 10
I understand that her voice was a bit broadway-ish..but wasn't that the case with Clay Aiken? That certainly hasn't stopped him from selling Pop records.
|
|
|
Post by Idol Obsessed on Feb 10, 2004 16:55:23 GMT 10
I'm upset we aren't getting this series of American Idol in NZ. It's obviously because NZ Idol is on now. It was interesting looking at the names of the contestants. I never knew Jesus lived in the Bronx. Go Jesus! I believe in you! lol! By the way, wats the goss with NZ Idol?
|
|
|
Post by SlackA on Feb 19, 2004 6:21:11 GMT 10
haha..just now ryan was like "never in my life would i think that ill ever say this but.. coming up next..JESUS!..whatsup jee!"
|
|
|
Post by dhm on Feb 19, 2004 23:35:40 GMT 10
I heard through the grapevine scooter girl may be back as a wild card. Not sure if this accurate but the source certainly believed it to be.
|
|
|
Post by AURORAB on Feb 24, 2004 19:36:55 GMT 10
I don't know if you guys noticed, but there were actually 36 contestants on stage when they took the pic of top 32 with Ryan. People were asking what happened to the other 4 on the American board. Those 4 were in the two rooms when the judges announced those who made it to top 32 too. I first noticed there were people missing because there was a black guy with yellow baseball cap in the room celebrating with them - and I thought it was good that he made it cause I already liked his voice from the little bit I heard from the audition on that same episode, and I was looking forward to hearing more. But he wasn't included in the contestant page. But he took the group pic with them on stage and they had that same pic on the official site when they first announced the top 32 -- he's the guy with yellow cap and knee lenght khaki shorts sitting at the front in the group pic with Ryan Seacrest. (if you tape the episode you can see it) Maybe they plan to bring him and the others back for Wildcard.
One of the contestants Heather piccinini mentioned in her Q & A on the site that there were top 36 before too. And Clay Aiken said top 36 in an interview some people saw. I guess they decided to cut it back. (season one had top 30. And season 2 had top 32)
here's her quote: What has been your proudest moment in life so far? My proudest moment in life so far has been making it this far in the America Idol Competition, making it to the top 36 is an achievement in itself.
|
|
|
Post by random on Feb 26, 2004 14:08:38 GMT 10
So they were told they'd made it when they hadn't really? Thats pretty bad!
|
|
|
Post by levi forever on Feb 29, 2004 15:20:14 GMT 10
The Romans might aswell have forgot the words. How awful were they?
|
|
|
Post by SlackA on Feb 29, 2004 18:36:03 GMT 10
^^ actually i agree with u.. their performance..was really bad..=\
i think it was the nerves
|
|