|
Post by David on Jul 18, 2004 12:54:13 GMT 10
I don't see why we need to compare the two.
|
|
hurley
Shower Crooner
its me
Posts: 17
|
Post by hurley on Jul 18, 2004 12:58:07 GMT 10
i think people font, and i find it disrespectful but i think that they do it because Gabriel is one of the major talents of Idol season 2 and i think they like to rate a possible idol up against THE IDOL
|
|
kell
Shower Crooner
Posts: 0
|
Post by kell on Jul 18, 2004 20:43:27 GMT 10
whoever started this thread should take a close look at him or her self this is not helping the contestants who got through, there is no dought that gaberil can sing guy has been singing in front of hundreds of poeple before australian idols in his church......
|
|
|
Post by prinia on Jul 18, 2004 20:53:47 GMT 10
I shouldn't really be posting. It is, as Edster said, a silly thread.
The original poster now has many who might have been possible supporters backs up.
Gabriel does have a very beautiful voice. However, he's got a long way to go with the personality and package. Hopefully he'll grow, like Guy did, and take advantage of all the criticism that will be thrown at him.
Lastly - because many of non-Guy fans are not fully aware of Guy's singing background because they weren't interested to find out - Guy had so much more experience than most - he'd sang in front of huge crowds for many years, (not just a few thousand), he had appeared on videos, he'd cut cds with Planet Shakers and Youth Alive, he'd found out and was teaching voice coaching, he was studying sound engineering or similar, he'd been in a couple of bands, he'd won a song competition, doing the whole thing in his own recording studio (someone in USA asked where they could buy the single, couldn't believe it wasn't a production number)...
When you look at all that - perhaps it was unfair on the other contestants last year (heh heh).
I am sure Aust will pick a new and deserving winner. I personally like Ngaire myself. But again - what we are seeing now should not be anything like we are going to see by the time the final 5 come down.
2 cents worth only
|
|
kell
Shower Crooner
Posts: 0
|
Post by kell on Jul 18, 2004 21:07:04 GMT 10
well said prinia, we should all do our home work before we compare singers etc, no one at this stage knows who gabreil is apart from the tv performance last week and will he make it to the next stage the top 40 my opinion he will but we are along way from the finals.
|
|
|
Post by concha on Jul 18, 2004 23:42:42 GMT 10
no way we love our fuzzy haired guy...
|
|
|
Post by prinia on Jul 19, 2004 21:01:49 GMT 10
Wooops, probably this is overkill..
after my large post above - but unless ppl had seen the ACA TV programme of so long ago now
I cannot wait until Guy does his Gospel album - he can ROCK GOSPEL like a dream..... blew me away, it was such a surprise...
|
|
|
Post by Jess on Jul 20, 2004 0:21:13 GMT 10
Clearly the person who made such a rich statement in the initial post was on crack.
You can't base an entire competition on the shoulders of a young man of whom you've heard sing for about 10 seconds and compare it with the likes of someone of whom you've watched grow and evolve for an entire year.
It won't happen. There's no comparison.
|
|
|
Post by jimmy on Jul 20, 2004 0:30:24 GMT 10
This is the most ridiculous thread what credit do u have, slickadenuravg04?
|
|
|
Post by Craven on Jul 21, 2004 13:44:35 GMT 10
I agree that this thread is full of ignorant individuals ... not casting that label on every single poster here ... just the idiots who post unjustifiable statements. It is not possible to make such a comparison. Gabriel and Guy are both individuals with unique talent and voices. Just like everybody here will like different music, ppl here will have their favours of their own artists. It doesn't however mean that one is 'better' than the other. I hope to see Gabriel develop into a great singer as the progression of the show continues and i have no doubt that he will but I will not listen to a bunch of ignoramus discredit Guy like a past hit wonder. He's achieved so much more than what some of you have done!!
|
|
|
Post by brian on Jul 21, 2004 14:07:01 GMT 10
well said graven, they are both human beings trying to make one day a living gabarel has good voice control so does guy good luck to them both....
|
|
|
Post by Liz unlogged on Jul 21, 2004 23:47:12 GMT 10
no way hun!! he's good but not as good as our GUY!! Starry Agree!!
|
|
|
Post by Greenleaf on Jul 22, 2004 23:13:39 GMT 10
Oh..him... His voice didn't stand out to me at all. But I do remember him because of Dicko's Ali G comment. Guy is better sorry.
|
|
|
Post by loin on Jul 22, 2004 23:31:33 GMT 10
greenleaf you do not stand out to me sorry guy is the past we are talking about A2 not A1 got it........ wake up to yourself FLING IS MY FAVORITE HOW ABOUT YOU
|
|
|
Post by Sheenia work on Jul 23, 2004 1:55:36 GMT 10
Hi Lion...
I believe guy is my favourite........and if I'm not wrong this whole thread is about Guy and Gabriel...so maybe you should open your eyes...
and guy is seriously an amazing talent........no comparing him to anyone for me..........
|
|